New editorial in the Three Broomsticks: “Is ‘Harry Potter’ a feminist text?”
In his new editorial, hpboy13 tackles a challenging topic in the fandom: Is Harry Potter a feminist text? There are definitely some strong female characters in the series, but these women (especially the unmarried ones) aren’t always treated in the same way as their male counterparts.
Here is a sample from this excellent editorial:
If HP were a feminist text, women like this [Rita Skeeter and Dolores Umbridge] would be celebrated. Instead, both of them are villains – they use illegal methods to advance themselves and make life a living hell for people. In short, we are very clearly supposed to hate both of these women.
In isolation, there is nothing wrong with having female villains; however, when the only two important unmarried women in the series are the two most detestable ones, we have a problem.
Is Jo’s treatment of her female protagonists problematic, or is Harry Potter a feminist series?