JKR: Some people will 'absolutely loathe' Book 7
The author JK Rowling is seen in a forthcoming TV documentary looking over the just-finished version of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows on her laptop. She declares: "Yeah, think I've finished."Ciaran's opinion: When she says readers could potentially loathe the book, it would be because of deaths. And I don't think Jo believes killing off any character(s) other than Harry would spark hate among fans, which could mean... (Consider that she's never said this about a previous book even though very beloved characters have died.)
As an off-camera film-maker offers his congratulations, Rowling, 41, says: "Thank you...yeah, you don't know, it might be rubbish. Some people will loathe it, they will absolutely loathe it. For some people to love it, other people must loathe it. That's just in the nature of the plot."
She adds, "I'm actually really, really happy with it", before bowing her head on the keyboard to exclaim: "Oh my God!"
Emerson's opinion: This could be interpreted to mean anything. I still don't believe Harry will die.
Posted by Ciaran on Jul 13th |
397 Comments


Visitor Comments













If Jo likes ot then I do to. I just hope Harry wont die but its JK Rowling who writes the books no me so she can do whatever she wants
OK well this is wat i think.... I have to disagree i absolutley hated the 5th book because Sirius i my all time favorite character in al the books i have read...and i was pretty mad about the sixth books end too..i actually think that it would be ok if Harry died... coming from a writer of many stories of my own...i think it would actually be approprate that Harry died..cause if she is only writing 7 books then in the end if Harry DIDNT die everyone would be like well wat happened to Harry and like all that but if she killed off Harry we kno that Neville would propbly be the next chosen one (see 5th book)...i have written many ends to the sereies when im bored (thats sounds really geeky) but yea i do and that is one of many ending i have written.. so you guys will probaly think i dont love Harry personally i like him.. hes just to...i dont kno...perfect in a way...and i think it would be cool to see Nevelle's sheild come down and he be the one to kill Voldemort...wat do you guys think????
I think Harry, Ron and Hermione do NOT die. Harry, however, never returns to the land of the living because he travels beyond the veil to battle it out with Voldemort- and this is why all his mentors had to die: because they are now beyond the veil. Harry will be seperated from his living friends, but he will be reunited with his parents, Dumbledore, and Sirius. Voldemort will be outrightly destroyed- no chance at becoming a ghost for him. Here's who i suspect die: Umbrisge, Voldemort, Hagrid (sobs), Aunt Petunia, Snape, and Wormtail
i don't think that i will loathe it because whatever happens is how it was meant to be. think about it, everything we've read is leading up to this book, so the ending will be perfect, no matter what it is! i read some of the comments though, and i would not be happy if what VshawnT 29 says comes true. :/ ONLY ONE MORE WEEK! :D
I seriously believe that harry will die. his death would be like the death of a close family member to me, howver i do believe that that would be the proper ending. harry survives at the end of every book..if he lives on this one..wouldnt it be so predictable? i think so...and a sade death...would give more emotion than a yay! after three thousand pages, harry still lives! it hasnt had many happy endings so far so.... he death is the most probable ending, i'd say
hey people...let´s face it...harry might really die... f*ckkkkkkkkkkkkkk kkkk
sigh. i think harry's a goner. that makes me sad :/ but if she DOES kill him off (i try and keep a little hope that she won't...haha) i hope she does it in a very touching and emotional way, and has good reason behind killing him. i really hope ron or hermione don't die....:[
K8y, I totally agree with you. Thank you :)
im pretty sure il LOVE it no matter what happens or who dies. after all i got through the death of my (really, really, really) beloved sirius so i think i csn pretty much get through anyone else's death!!! omg i cannot explain how im feeling right now, im soooooooo excitied it unreal and im so sad that it's coming to an end! im also scared that i wont be able to stop crying long enough to actually read the book!!
i hope i love the book!!! hopefully harry wont die ): 7 more days!!! wooo hooo
If either Hermione or Ron dies, there will be plenty of people who will still loathe the book, even if Harry survives. People would be bitter about other Weasleys dying as well. (Personally, I doubt both twins will survive.) There are plenty of other reasons people might loathe the book, it doesn't just mean that Harry must be dying. That's an awfully big assumption on the part of this news report.
i don't want harry to die, but if he does, i won't be suprised, but if hermione or ron dies, i think i will cry harder b/c then we won't see then in love..... but i still don't want harry to die, although i am pretty sure he might, which would be maddening b/c then what was the point of harry's parents saving him.....why would he live this long just to die....... argh!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i am so ready for this BOOK!!!
wait for it....okay....WHEN DUMBLEDORE FELL OFF THE FLIPPIN TOWER HE ACTUALLY LANDED IN A GIANT BARREL OF CHEESECAKE AND SOME CATS...WHEN SIRIUS WAS HIT BY THE SPELL, THERE WAS ACTUALLY A VERY THICK BEANPOLE THAT WAS ON THE INSIDE HIS JACKET THAT THE SPELL HIT AND HE WAS ACTUALLY TRANSPORTED INTO THAT GIANT BARREL OF CHEESECAKE....SOOO.....DU MBLY AND SIRIUS ARE BIDING THEIR TIME LIKE TWO DIRTBURGLARS UNTIL THE TIME IS RIGHT TO STRIKE LIKE DRUNKEN HYIENAS!jk
mugglenet you need to disable comments right now so people wont spoil the book!
I won't hate the book if Harry, or anyone, dies but of course I'll be really sad about it. I don't want any of them to die. It wont be something that would make you loathe the books and if Harry or Ron or Hermione does die, then that's what was meant to be...obviously. Anyway, I really don't want them to die. It'll be so sad. Gah... I need the bookkkk. This next week is going to kill me.
If you want to know if Ron, Hermione, and Harry die, and you believe Emerson when he says that Rowling answered that question before she became famous, then check out this youtube video: do a search for: JKR Story Emerson. For those who don’t want to be spoiled STOP reading now! For those who do want to know, keep reading. If you don’t want to know for 7 more days…please exercise some self control and read the next comment. Ok. Rowling said none of the trio dies in the ending. How’s that for a surpise!
omg, if you could do anything to up the hype a bit more, that would bit it!
Thank you irma_babuci! :-)
JO WE ALL LOVE YOU AND I THINK PEOPLE WILL STYILL LOVE IT BBUT HOW WOULD WE FEAL GOING TO GO WATCH HALF-BLOOD PRINCE KNOWING HARRY DIES? TELL ME HOW YOU GUYS WOULD FEAL .. I WOULD FEAL AWFULL SAEING HARRY KISSING GINNY AND BEING HAPPY THEN KNOWING HE'LL DIE SO.. i really hope harry does not die but i think maybe luna and ginny will die SO GUYS HOW WOULD YOU FEAL GOING TO GO WATCH HBP AND KNOWING HARRY DIES? .. TELL ME
NOW look at all the people who think Harry will die. Where were you yesterday????? Even though there are some people still ignoring reason. Loathe is a strong word. Just because you don't like some of the revelations you've been waiting for (maybe the horcruxes are a disappointment) doesn't mean you'll loathe the book. You might dislike it or hate it. To LOATHE it means that something has to happen that you wish JKR didn't do, not something that you were just disappointed in. And that would be killing Harry. I'm not going to hate it if he dies. Id probably have a bigger chance of hating it if he lived, kind of a boring, anticlimactic ending to a seven book long series.
JUST THE THOUGHT THAT THIS PROVES THE CHANCE THAT HARRY MIGHT DIE IS GREATER.. I'M BALLING MY EYES OUT ALREADY CUZ I JUST CAN'T IMAGINE HARRY POTTER DYING.. HE JUST CAN'T.. I CAN'T ACCEPT IT.. IF HE DIES THEN I WILL LOATHE THIS BOOK.. YES JO IS RIGHT.. i hope he doesn't die.. OMG.. u can't kill harry.
i really really really do NOT want ron or hermione to die bc they are like my favorite characters...along with a few others. so if that means she will kill off harry instead (i doubt she would kill off the whole trio, or even 2 of them) then i am ok with that. but still i hate reading the deaths :-(.
but u know what, to some who say it will be predictable for harry to live.....well aren't we mostly predicting harry will die, i mean, deep down we all know harry is the likely one to die, so what if jk almost killed him, but with some twist someone stepped in......... so to all who are saying that if harry lived, the book would ending to softly...well obviously that would be wrong b/c of other character we love who are going to die...... don't hate on harry, he is the reason for the book, although if it was a choice to have him die over ron and hermione, i would pick harry any day just so ron and hermione could be together, I STiLL LOVE 'ARRY THOUGH!!!!!! *bawling*
Some people hate some things and in the same time others love it! It wasn't necessary to say.. there's a differents kinds of taste. When she said that.. i thought about Harry dying.. NOOO.. i dont want this..
OMG OMG OMG! Go JK! *does a little dance* Ill love it no matter what, i mean, its the LAST OF HARRY POTTER! Mayb some ppl wont like it because theyre delusional H/Hr shippers. idk.... As long as Ginny is ok, but I doubt she will, cuz Voldy kills everyone close to harry. At least well c Bill's wedding. or maybe the death eaters crash that too...
Well, if I even see HBP, after suffering through OoTP, then I'll think "this is just a movie meant to make money off of JKR's idea, and she had the right to kill Harry because it was her creation." Same with the theme park. And I agree, I'd rather Harry died than Ron or Hermione. And hpgirl21053, by your standards any ending to DH is predictable. Lets look at this: we know he must live or die. Yes, those are two mutually exclusive events, so one must happen or the other must happen. If we're done understanding that, you'll see that there are (on a simple level) two possible endings. So both are predictable in a way. It would just be cornier and expected if Harry lived.
please, could somrone tell me why lots of you think that harry is a horcrux????? no, I really would like some answers out there when I get back on the computer after supper! please!
JO WE ALL LOVE YOU AND I THINK PEOPLE WILL STYILL LOVE IT BBUT HOW WOULD WE FEAL GOING TO GO WATCH HALF-BLOOD PRINCE KNOWING HARRY DIES? TELL ME HOW YOU GUYS WOULD FEAL .. I WOULD FEAL AWFULL SAEING HARRY KISSING GINNY AND BEING HAPPY THEN KNOWING HE'LL DIE SO.. i really hope harry does not die but i think maybe luna and ginny will die SO GUYS HOW WOULD YOU FEAL GOING TO GO WATCH HBP AND KNOWING HARRY DIES? .. TELL ME
ahhh hopefully this isnt true! even if someone i like dies, ill still love it. who wont??
I would love this last book even if she killed every single one of my favorite characters. Everything Jo puts into her books is for a reason, so I'm sure she will make it all come together perfectly no matter what. I'd like to point out, however, that Hermione is just as likely to die as Ron. They've been equals throughout the entire series (as opposed to the movies that make Hermione a more major character) and to kill just one of them would throw everything off balance. So I'm thinking if one's dead, the other will follow suit so that they can be dead together (although I doubt that will happen, and pray it doesn't).
The 7th book probable chapter titles: 1. The Dark Hollow 2. Flowery Affection 3. Solace by Owl 4. The Secret Escort 5. A Nightly Arrival 6. Jollity at the Burrow 7. One Golden Day 8. The Inescapable Path 9. The Marble Village 10. Fragmented Memories 11. An Elfish Lead 12. Gobbledygook 13. The Medieval Key 14. The Fiery Crypt 15. Dragon’s Horde 16. The Mist-Shrouded Castle 17. The Grey Lady’s Desire 18. His Relics of Death 19. Hogsmeade in Christmas 20. Aberforth’s Teachings 21. The Malfoy Manor 22. Trinkets and Treasures 23. Viratrendum 24. A Prince Unveiled 25. Kreacher’s Deceit 26. Deadly Sacrifices 27. He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named 28. A Burden Fulfilled 29. The Archaic Runes 30. The Crusade Begins 31. All Manner of Creatures 32. A Debt Settled 33. Through the Timeless Passage 34. The Dark Lord’s Fury 35. The End Hallo!!!
I knew it! i knew we'd get some news about DH today ..even its not from jo directly..we got some *squee* I doubt I'll loathe it though..however she wants to finish it im sure I'll love it!
I might just loathe it if there's just too many deaths. I know this will be about the Wizarding War, and there will be deaths... but a high body count will just become tedious and frankly annoying (like Harry’s pubescent crisis in Order of the Phoenix). The deaths will lose all value and the reader will get bored if characters (either major or minor, or even just the mention of some random person) snuff it at every other page, whether they be good, bad or neutral.
Killing Harry would make me use up a box of Kleenex, but it wouldn't make me hate the book if it's well done (and I'm sure it would be). I'd be more likely to hate the book if it turns out Dumbledore asked Snape to kill him. I still can't believe so many people think so...
7 days till the 7th book and its Friday the 13th. Creepy stuff, man. Creepy stuff.
i hope i'm not one of the people that loathe it!!!!!!
rob15, that has been my theory for a long time too. if people would just read between the lines they would see how obvious it really is!!!!
Yes! More proof that Harry will die and Voldy wont! I may sound ridiculous here, but I think voldy should suffer "a thing worse than death". Like being made mortal, have your magic taken away, and being locked in a room FILLED with Dobbys. Good ending, eh?
I'm going to cry just because it's going to be over. That's going to be the worst thing about it. i think it's going to be a weasley who dies. oh, gosh. i don't want to read this book!!!!! it's going to break my heart
This is what i was waiting for.Last time too Jo said like this before HBP.Confirms harry dies.I will love it Jo.That's my theory that harry dies and voldemort dies too.My strange theory is that harry wont kill voldemort,but because of harry, he dies.Stupid i know
I'm sooooooo NOT ready for next Saturday.... SOOOOO not ready.... I keep thinking what I'm gonna do if I read the book and I find out that Harry dies. But the most important thing is that after this book, all the wonderful experiences I've gone trough these past few years thanks to these books will be gone... I am also experiencing a sort of "dilema" because I live in Argentina and I'm the only member of my family who will read the book as soon as it comes out, because neither my mom nor my sister speak English, and they're both huge fans, too. So, next Saturday I'll be either jumping up and down with joy or cryin' my heart out, and I'll have to hide those feelings so as not to spoil their experience... I can foresee some looooooong hours alone in my bedroom... I just want to say that no matter what happens in this final episode, I will be forever thankful to Jo for showing us the magical world she has built. Have a nice final week, everyone!!!
maddyvoldy: It IS pretty stupid, to tell you the truth. xD
I don't think at all that people loathing her because of the deaths points to Harry, there are MANY well-loved characters by many different people. Imagine the uproar if Fred or George died?
She's sooo talking about SNAPE.
I don't know....I do think ever since the death in HBP no one in the books is safe. My hunch is both LV and Harry will die but would she kill the main character ? We'll see...
In reply to VshawnT's comment about Ron dying- in Mugglenet's book "What will happen in book 7- who lives, who dies, who falls in love and how does the adventure finally end?" they have a quote from J.K.R. saying "like I would kill off [Harry's] best mate" or ... something. So I'd like to think she'd stick to that and not kill off Ron! :( But I"m still worried for Harry. and I agree w/ someone's comment who said if Harry does die then he lived a pretty "crummy" 17 years. didn't really get to relax or have a life :(. Not to mention if he dies that will be sooo sad to watch in the movie! :'(.
I'll like it. I'll force myself to like it. Even if it sucks. :]
I know I'll be furious if she kills off Remus. If that happens, I'll probably put the book somewhere out of site and not read it again. Or Fenrir. I just want one of the werewolves to make it! But there are some I think I would literally jump up and squeal for joy if they died. Which would probably be a stupid thing to do at the wee hours of the morning, lol!
Doesn't ANYONE believe in Happy Endings anymore? Don't you think it's possible that ALL loved charachters will live, and the two major deaths will be evil people. HARRY HAS TO LIVE!!!! It would be pointless to tell this story about a boy with an awful, terrible life, then kill him! EVERYONE has to live *go cries in a corner*
NOT HARRY! PLEASE! or Tonks...
Back to Top