JKR: Some people will 'absolutely loathe' Book 7
JKR: Some people will 'absolutely loathe' Book 7 ITV is set to broadcast a documentary on JK Rowling this winter called "A Year in the Life...JK Rowling," and some excerpts from the special have been released.
The author JK Rowling is seen in a forthcoming TV documentary looking over the just-finished version of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows on her laptop. She declares: "Yeah, think I've finished."

As an off-camera film-maker offers his congratulations, Rowling, 41, says: "Thank you...yeah, you don't know, it might be rubbish. Some people will loathe it, they will absolutely loathe it. For some people to love it, other people must loathe it. That's just in the nature of the plot."

She adds, "I'm actually really, really happy with it", before bowing her head on the keyboard to exclaim: "Oh my God!"
Ciaran's opinion: When she says readers could potentially loathe the book, it would be because of deaths. And I don't think Jo believes killing off any character(s) other than Harry would spark hate among fans, which could mean... (Consider that she's never said this about a previous book even though very beloved characters have died.)

Emerson's opinion: This could be interpreted to mean anything. I still don't believe Harry will die.
Posted by Ciaran on Jul 13th | 397 Comments
Visitor Comments
Posted by Bellatrix81 Jul 14th 2007

Lord Voldemort and snape will die... by the way snape will be the hero ... cuz he is Good!!


Posted by jens Jul 14th 2007

Ugh! I'm kinda scared to even read the book cuz if Harry dies I'm gonna cry. Harry's had a hard enough life already so if he dies it'll be like pouring salt into a wound!!


Posted by lrbaker89 Jul 14th 2007

I'm pretty sure she's referring to the fact that this is the final book, and, everyone, by now, has decided a way they think the series should end. However, the series will end by the hand of JKRowling, and no one else. Therefore, some will love it, and some will hate it. It just depends...I don't however think that she is referring to the fact that the deaths in the book are going to cause a massive uproar.


Posted by Hermione713 Jul 14th 2007

Hmm...you know, even if I didn't like the ending, I don't think I could ever HATE a Harry Potter book. It's JKR--the woman's a genius, and we finally get to see the way she intended it to play out. People can still always read and write fanfic if they're really not satisfied with DH. If there's one thing I "loathe," it's that the series is at an end...*sniff*...so, I'll still treasure DH, no matter who dies or what happens.


Posted by jt7377 Jul 14th 2007

Also remeber that JKR did not say that the fans will loathe the plot, but "some people". That could mean anything. It probably has nothing to do with who lives and dies in the book. There are those small minded people who never read the book, but loathe it enough to burn it. So do not read to much into this.


Posted by s1pixie Jul 14th 2007

Not that I don't think characters are going to die, but if Ciaran thinks that deaths are all that can inspire hate among fans, he's obviously forgotten the drama that went on with all the Harry/Hermione shippers who couldn't handle Jo confirming that Hermione will end up with Ron. That had nothing to do with character death, and if sending book jackets back to JKR as a sign of protest can't be classified as hate, I don't know what can. I agree with Emerson...Jo's comment could mean anything. And for the record, I can't imagine myself loathing the book, no matter how it ends.


Posted by kraziek Jul 14th 2007

NO i dont want harry to die!!!!!!!!!!!! i am going to love this book, even though there are going to be deaths!!! :( i dont care what she thinks i am going to love this book!!!! i just dont want the series to be over!:'(


Posted by zsedc232232 Jul 14th 2007

Harry is sooo going to die, he's the only one on the front cover! And the person who dies is always on the front cover, Querill was on the cover of the first, the Basilik was on the second, Buckbeak (no one died but Buckbeak was sposed to die) was on the third, Cedric on the fourth, Serius on the fifth, Dumbledore on the sixth. HARRY only on the seventh. Unless tradition is wrong, Harry's gonna die.


Posted by gred123 Jul 14th 2007

I agree with Emerson. There's no way she'll kill off Harry.


Posted by Hermione713 Jul 14th 2007

Yes, I don't think Harry's going to die, either. By the way, isn't Voldemort on the cover, too? If the cover theory follows through, it could just as well be meant for him. Good point, s1pixie: the shipping thing also ticked off a lot of people. Hmmm, I wonder if JKR ever just sits down and laughs hysterically over how much people read into every ambiguous thing she says. :)


Posted by jt7377 Jul 14th 2007

Hey guys..... I am re-reading HBP and I think I have found proof that Harry is not a Horcrux, which may help his chances of survival. On pages 503-513. Harry and Dumbledore discuss the possible 7 Horcruxes. Dumbledore mentions on the night Harry was to be murdered, Voldy was going to make his final Horcrux. Dumbledore explains that he failed. Dumbledore also states that the final Horcrux was made when he used Nagini to kill the old man at the beginning of GoF. Dumbledore also explains that the last part of Voldy's soul to attack is the one in his body, so Harry MUST live to fight that final piece.


Posted by Zen127 Jul 14th 2007

i hope hagrid lives and Harry too...i dont rlly care hermione dies tho


Posted by BeeBlack Jul 14th 2007

I'm pretty sure I will be one of the ppl who will loathe the book, because I have a awful feeling Ron is gonna die. Snif snif


Posted by NickiG Jul 14th 2007

I'm excited. I would love for a happily ever after ending. With Harry and Ginny together and Ron and Hermione together. And Voldy dead and the wizarding world at peace once more. But I don't control these things so what ever happens...happens. And I will deal with it. Although in my gut, I dont THINK she will kill Harry. But I am occasionaly wrong. :]


Posted by GrownUpChick Jul 14th 2007

I don't really understand why people think Harry won't die. I believe he will. He has to in order to get rid of Voldemort. The best way to avoid having anyone else try to cash in on this phenomenon by writing their own Harry Potter books is to kill him off. Also, Jo has stated that she cried alot when she finished "Deathy Hallows" and that she will "miss Harry". I think it's obvious he will die and I'll be very surprised if he lives. The hero always dies in the end, doesn't he? Harry will be sacrificed in order to save not only all of Wizardkind, but the entire world.


Posted by siriuslives Jul 14th 2007

i think she says people will loathe because it's the last one. there will be no more harry potter books. :( i loathe deathly hallows because of this.


Posted by What_the_Juice Jul 14th 2007

I personally would be sadder if Ron or Hagrid died than if Harry died. I am actually expecting Harry to die. Besides, I like Ron and Hagrid better xP


Posted by hermioneswand Jul 14th 2007

Well here's hoping that Harry doesn't die coz I'll cry my butt off like I did during the 5th movie this evening but bring on the good stuff. Her books just keep getting better.


Posted by Teryl Jul 15th 2007

I will like the book no matter what...


Posted by Divster Jul 15th 2007

i definately gonna luv it!!!!!!!!!!!!! but yea i think she's talking about the ppl who r gonna die. if harry dies :(, it's probably gonna be cuz he has 2 sacrifice himself 4 voldemort to die or something. god i just cant wait 4 da book!!!!!!!!


Posted by jacki3 Jul 15th 2007

I will surely love it. I know it would mean all night crying why all those characters die and a year of dreaming i'm one of the cast in the book. hehe I hope it has loads of Ron&Hermione moments. lol xox


Posted by princess_horcrux Jul 15th 2007

I really hope she doesn't kill off harry! Even if she does it'll be for a good reason e.g. to make an emotional impact/ make the story more intricate. It'll be an amazing book no matter what, i don't think it'll ruin it for ppl when ppl die, it'll be sad but if it's a part of the plot i'm sure there'll be a point to it... oooh i wonder of draco's gna die?


Posted by godricsquid Jul 15th 2007

Harry Potter cannot die! Those bloody idiots are just saying that to let everyone down. Okay Harry dying WOULD NOT make sense i cannot imagine Harrys body just lying on the floor.....d-dead*shudders * What the heck was the point of even making up the story if hes going to die anyways. J.k. Rowling might as well of made Voldemort kill him when he was a baby. Most people think hes going to die and that means hes going to live because she would not put the obvious thing. But if he does die I will not cry [cause I didnt when Ced, Dumbledore and Sirius did] or maybe I will dunno and guess what She cant answer all the guestions. Oh yes she can because the only bloody reason she put those mysterys in the story is because they all add up to something in the end they are not just going to be some dumb what is this ?answers anyways Harry will live and if he doesnt then atleast he'll live on the book pages forever and the story of harry potter will live forever in our hearts


Posted by godricsquid Jul 15th 2007

I completely agree with emerson .I also agree that Harry is too strong to die and voldy is growing weaker.[I love the DH cover for the book} Everyone knows its impossible for Harry to die [and yes voldy you cant kill him off]


Posted by JamesD122 Jul 15th 2007

As long as Ginny and Harry get back together and both live. Im Happy :P


Posted by MagicQuill Jul 15th 2007

I'd still love the book even if harry dies or if something like that happend.


Posted by hp_books_rox Jul 15th 2007

I think you r right Emerson


Posted by Maverick152004 Jul 15th 2007

As long as Ron, Hermione,...or well, any Weasley doesn't die, I'll be ok. I'll recover from anyone else. God bless


Posted by crookshanks800 Jul 15th 2007

I don't believe Harry will die. I think the reason JKR believes some people with loathe it is because it WILL have a happy ending. The people who want Harry to die will loathe it.


Posted by MiracleMira Jul 15th 2007

I'm sorry I wanna say that I'll love the books even if Harry dies but I won't ... any other character I can (kind of) understand but there is no way that his death can be a good ending, no matter how well written and heroic ... this isn't Brad Pitts character in Troy it's Harry Potter I will be very disapointed if he doesn't survive(oh and him loosing his magic and living as a muggle is just as good so yeah not gonna happen)


Posted by znoah08 Jul 15th 2007

idk could mean anything and to be honest I think I would be less upset about Harry dying than when dumbledore died. Whatever happens I wont hate it though


Posted by darkatheart33 Jul 15th 2007

Harry's gonna die!! It'll b sad but she's gonna kill him. I just know it. Either way i'll never say i hate the book...i'm too obsessed to say that


Posted by GAPgal Jul 15th 2007

OMG..i hope Harry doesn't die. But, even if he does we all need to move on. I will be sad either way...LESS THAN A WEEK LEFT!!!!! (so excited)


Posted by GAPgal Jul 15th 2007

I will NEVER loathe Harry Potter.!!!!(btw Voldemort is NOT on the cover)


Posted by muggle123 Jul 15th 2007

I think what she means by some people absolutely loathing the book can be taken in two ways: It is either that Harry dies, and of course millions of fans don't want that and would hate it, OR it could be that Harry doesn't die because we know from watching debates and media stories that millions of fans think the only appropriate ending would be Harry dying. I don't think JKR would say a comment with such a meaning as that and mean for it to only be taken one way!!!! We know from experience that JKR doesn't say things unless she wants us to know before-hand!


Posted by godricsquid Jul 15th 2007

HARRY WILL NOT DIE AND ALL THOSE IDIOTS OUT THERE THAT THINK HE WILL WILL SUFFER AS HARD AS VOLDEMORT WILL SUFFER IN THE END!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !![AND THAT IS SAYING ALOT] AND ALL YOU PEOPLE WHO LOVE SUFFERING[HONESTLY THE GENES PEOPLE INHERIT] WELL YOU'LL LIVE A JOYFUL LIFE. BEAT THAT PEOPLES


Posted by iamravenclaw Jul 15th 2007

i cant say that im gonna love it im cant say im gonna hate it all i can say is please I DONT WANT TO HATE IT!!! please let me love it!! AAHHH...im afraid of what it holds


Posted by ypt_madz Jul 15th 2007

well i don't want harry to die but that would be the best thing to happen. if you look at this way if she didn't kill off harry somone else could go and write other prequels and this would be extreamly bad for J.K Rowling so even though i never want Harry to die i think he will.


Posted by appleman24 Jul 15th 2007

This doesn't mean anyone is dieing. It just means that some credits will think its bad. It is that way with every book. Some like it, some don't.


Posted by sarahbutter Jul 15th 2007

I honestly don't think Harry will die. I mean, he has this crappy life just to die in the end and then evil conquers good?


Posted by Kay Jul 15th 2007

Well, i don't think this is proof that harry dies. just because she says some people will "loathe" it, it doesn't necessarily mean it's just because the main character will die. i mean, if your favorite characters are fred and george, and suddenly they get bumped off for no real reason other than to show the real nature of war or wutever, then you're going to really hate the book. muffins, i know a guy who's going to despise the book if harry's not a horcrux, snape is really evil, and dumbledore's really dead. oh, and something about aunt petunia being a horcrux, too... >rolls eyes< anyway, it could really mean anything.... they could just not like the book cuz of its plot...


Posted by Quidditch_Player Jul 16th 2007

I've always been a Ron / Hermione shipper =)


Posted by EmmaGrangerr_3 Jul 16th 2007

I think that whatever happens I will never hate the book. Too much has happened that i have loved in these books for me to ever hate them!No matter who dies and who doesn't!


Posted by HermionesCrookshanks Jul 16th 2007

Harry will not die. Harry will not die. Harry will NOT die. I hope.... even if he does, I hope he takes Voldemort down with him... If he doesn't I might just hunt Jo down...if I can even find her... Eh, oh well. I just cannot believe FOUR MORE DAYS! -Jo- I will NEVER EVER hate Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, no matter what the hell happens to Harry. You are my favourite author, and you ROCK! Well, I guess that's enough for now! ~Crookshanks~


Posted by godricsquid Jul 16th 2007

I know harry doesnt die because I found out all the chapter titles already[but i havent read the book]


Posted by zsedc232232 Jul 16th 2007

Well, both Harry and Voldy-mort could die. The prophosy never said that wellVoldy-mort is laughing hystaricaly about killing Harry, Ron couldn't send a little Advada Cadavera at his back. Just a thought.


Posted by Narcissa_Black Jul 16th 2007

i really hope she doesnt kill off harry, hes my favorite character (after sirius, but seeing as hes dead...) i dont see how people could loathe the books, even if harry dies it will still be an amazing book to me, killing off harry would be like ruining the last hope of good, i mean, dumbledore was the onnly one You-Know-Who ever feared and now that hes dead, if harry dies (even if he kills You-Know-Who) it will seem like hope, love and good die with him.






Translate


MuggleNet is an unofficial Harry Potter fan site. Please email us if you have any questions or concerns. MuggleNet's original layouts were designed and created by Navy. All subsequent layouts by Dylan Spartz.

© 1999-2008 MuggleNet.com. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy | COPPA Policy | Feedback | Credits
Random Addresses

1,377 muggles currently online


Poll
How many Potter-related items are on your holiday wish list this year?

Updates
Today's Updates
· Opened new Beedle the Bard contest [November 22]
Recent Updates
· Updated weekly Caption Contest [November 17]
· Added Ministry of Magic Polling Center [November 1]
Mail

Quotes
Make way for the Heir of Slytherin, seriously evil wizard [Harry] coming through...

Fred and George Weasley
Chamber of Secrets, Chapter 12, Page 210

See Another Quote
Big News
(11/14) - Warner Brothers releases new Half-Blood Prince trailer!
(10/26) - New Half-Blood Prince international teaser trailer!
(9/08) - WB/RDR Trial Verdict: Judge halts Lexicon publication
(8/14) - Half-Blood Prince delayed until July 17th, 2009
(6/11) - JK Rowling's Harry Potter Prequel now online!
(6/10) - Potter Prequel sells for 25k pounds
Release Dates
Beedle the Bard:
December 4th, 2008
The Exhibition:
Spring 2009
Deathly Hallows paperback:
July 7th, 2009
Half-Blood Prince:
July 17th, 2009
Wizarding World:
2010
Deathly Hallows, Pt 1:
November 19, 2010
Deathly Hallows, Pt 2:
May 2011

Advertisement




MuggleNet » Fan Site Award Winner