The Guardian reveals opening of Deathly Hallows?
The Guardian reveals opening of Deathly Hallows? With extreme caution for lack of authenticity, we bring you this article from The Guardian's online website. It holds, what they say, is the opening to Deathly Hallows dated October 23rd, 2006.

According to their site, this small portion can be seen in video from the upcoming JK Rowling documentary we told you about a few days ago.

We've posted it in the black area below in case it is removed from The Guardian's website. Highlight in between the arrows if you wish to read.

-->'Chapter One. The Dark Lord Ascending. The two men appeared out of nowhere, a few yards apart in the narrow, moonlit lane. For a second they stood quite still, wands pointing at each other's chests: then, recognising each other, they stowed their wands beneath their cloaks and set off, side by side, in the same direction.

"News?", asked the taller of the two.

"The best," replied Snape.'
<--

Please remember that it is still unknown as to whether or not this is real. Interesting, nonetheless. Thanks to everyone who e-mailed with the tip!

Emily's edit: I emailed Andrew saying I didn't think the excerpt was real. Here's why: There is a mixture of British/English grammar - the British spelling of "recognise" and the American use of "a few yards." There are also odd punctuation errors - a colon after "chest" and then ?", when only a question mark before the quotation mark would be used. Would Jo really make these errors? We'll find out soon.
Posted by Andrew on Jul 14th | 1648 Comments
Visitor Comments
Posted by FireFenix Jul 15th 2007

Wow. Wow. Die, Snape. Can't wait till the real one come out.


Posted by Quidditch_Player Jul 15th 2007

Waiting for Friday! ^_^


Posted by jhonnyboi91 Jul 15th 2007

I think Snape is talking to someone from the order. Yet i might be wrong, it could be too soon in the book to assume snape is good.


Posted by AnnOminous Jul 15th 2007

I find this whole situation quite amusing. ;)


Posted by DanielRadcliffeIsSEXY Jul 15th 2007

Widdi2k7: What happens? WHAT HAPPENS? Harry doesn't die, right?


Posted by PirateEmery Jul 15th 2007

It's FAKE, people. I can tell that the scans have been doctored and that there are many contradictions everywhere.


Posted by Spleeny Jul 15th 2007

This is REAL. Keep in mind, she could have changed around the wording, but the chapter title IS real. I saw a few scans of the book by accident on another site. A couple chapters WITH THE ARTWORK were shown. Of course, I clicked back as soon as I realized it was definitely a real spoiler. There was a store where the book got out early...


Posted by DanielRadcliffeIsSEXY Jul 15th 2007

Peta's evidence looks pretty convincing, but I still doubt this is real. Either it's fake, or Jo must of been snorting something while writing DH.


Posted by James_Padfoot Jul 15th 2007

*nods* Spleeny is right. The chapter title is real, and another 35 chapters follow with an epilogue. I have to just say that shippers of a certain ship will be using a certain chapter artwork for their avatars in some time to come.


Posted by Spleeny Jul 15th 2007

I didn't look to see any of the pictures beyond the first one I saw. I read the first eight chapter titles, but now I forget most of them, and I'm glad. I learned my lesson with Snape Kills Dumbledore...I saw the scans, thought they were fake, laughed and told everyone I knew, then when I got the book, I opened it to that page just to make sure it wasn't there...and thought, "Oops."


Posted by Bezoar Jul 15th 2007

maybe its real, maybe its not.....still doesn't tell us much. Why are people intent on finding out as much as they can anyways? And why, why, WHY does mugglenet keep posting stuff like this? Why can't mugglenet be a spoiler-free zone like the forums? It makes all the hard work we do in the forums to combat spoilers completely pointless. I might be completely wrong, but don't nearly ALL the members of CoS also come to Mugglenet everyday? You would think we could synchronize these things......ugh, stupid.


Posted by tristero07 Jul 15th 2007

Come on, those were fake. A word should be capitalized in one of the chapter titles that isn't. If any mistake in the book is caught srely it would be in the names of the chapters.


Posted by SlytherinHalfBloodPrince Jul 15th 2007

Mmmm.... I don't think it's real... maybe it is... who knows... well JKR and a some more, but... guess we'll have to see on Friday night!


Posted by pshorty Jul 15th 2007

Honestly? Don't think it's real. Recognizing is spelled wrong. And it just doesn't seem enough JK to me.


Posted by DanielRadcliffeIsSEXY Jul 15th 2007

James_Padfoot: Which ship? H/HR? Hr/R? HP/LL? H/G? N/L? D/P? HBP/DEATH? Tell me!!!!


Posted by OxfordGirl727 Jul 15th 2007

wow would she really do this? i dont think its true


Posted by Spleeny Jul 15th 2007

British people spell recognizing with an S, I think. The only reason those chapter titles may be wrong is the ones I read seem like things that could've been figured out from the other books and hints JKR is given...there didn't seem to be anything profoundly knew (like "Horcruxes" in HBP). Then again, I glanced too quickly to judge much, and there IS artwork.


Posted by Ravleen Jul 15th 2007

For those talking about how some parts like un-JKR like, this is from October, revisions and edits have certainly been made since then, so if it's awkwardly written at all, I'm sure she's fixed it. :) I've gotten over my grumpiness at being spoiled, this isn't too huge. But I am not clicking on any chapter links, etc.


Posted by greenphoenix Jul 15th 2007

Nice. That means that those chapter titles that those tossers have been posting are false.


Posted by jfebery Jul 15th 2007

Recognizing isn't spelled wrong. That's the way it's spelled in England.


Posted by James_Padfoot Jul 15th 2007

Oxford girl, note that Jo didn't do this. She wants us to be spoiler free. WE are the one being the idiots and spoiling ourselves and then headesking for our idiocy. DanielRadcliffeisSEXY, you'll see =) I don't want to spoil this book for anyone, and what I have already done to myself I am in the process of forgetting XD


Posted by LadyM Jul 15th 2007

meh. Not Jo's style.


Posted by UnspeakableMT Jul 15th 2007

For those saying JK wouldn't just introduce a character by name last name alone, I think we should take into consideration that this book doesn't take place a month after the last one, but rather, almost instantly. At least, that's what I've picked up from reading info about the book.


Posted by PirateEmery Jul 15th 2007

Artwork can be mimicked.


Posted by Bob_Oggdon Jul 15th 2007

Just Keep an eye on JKRs rubbish bin on her site....if she denies it you no it crap if she doesnt then ...well....maybe...


Posted by DanielRadcliffeIsSEXY Jul 15th 2007

James_Padfoot: Lemme guess. It's Ron and Hermione making out. Or it's Harry and Ginny making out! Which one?


Posted by Spleeny Jul 15th 2007

Ugh, it is so late and I'm making typos of all sorts. Sigh. Anyway! It takes a pretty pathetic person to mimic the artwork just to bother some fans. That makes me hope those were real and that no one would take the time to throw us off so much!


Posted by Teryl Jul 15th 2007

Interesting. I cannot decide if it is fake...Oh, well, I can wait five more days. Or can I... :O Ya, I can.


Posted by DanielRadcliffeIsSEXY Jul 15th 2007

James_Padfoot: Lemme guess. It's Ron and Hermione making out. Or it's Harry and Ginny making out! Which one? James_Padfoot: Lemme guess. It's Ron and Hermione making out. Or it's Harry and Ginny making out! Which one? James_Padfoot: Lemme guess. It's Ron and Hermione making out. Or it's Harry and Ginny making out! Which one?


Posted by PirateEmery Jul 15th 2007

Trust me, I read a 700+ version of Deathly Hallows which I deemed to be fake. It has absolutely no relation (chapter title wise) to the Deathly Hallows that is cited in this link. If someone would go through the motions of writing a 700+ fan fiction, I think someone could easily make those chapter art.


Posted by thetictacisback Jul 15th 2007

haha omg thats cool. dont know if its real or not..hm..but i couldnt resist i had to read it. and then someone copied and pasted it to me on msn so i couldnt hide from it haha cant believe how close it is :)


Posted by hpfandudebruh Jul 15th 2007

I saw some scans of the table of contents from the U.S. edition of DH online earlier today. i didn't read all of them because i didn't want to spoil it for myself. but whether you choose to believe me or not, i can confirm that the title of chapter one is indeed "the dark lord ascending," so this information is probably accurate. i'm not one of those spoiler-people who likes to ruin everything for everyone else, so i won't tell you any of the other chapter titles (although they're pretty easy to find on the internet if you look.) and besides, this kind of sounds like it's written by j.k. rowling, anyway. (my bet is that snape's talking to either voldemort or some other death eater.)


Posted by Gwen079 Jul 15th 2007

I'm going to feel bad after saying this if it was really true, but I don't think it was real. I dunno, just doesn't sound like her writing. Plus, I think they're smart enough to keep the cameras away from the book before it comes out.


Posted by Puddly Jul 15th 2007

I shouldn't read it, but I did. I shouldn't read the comments either, but I did. GAH! I need anything that will sustain me for five days. It's like being starved with an accessible piece of steak hanging inches away from your face. And yet, you cannot bite it! In any case, I think it's real, just not the finalized version.


Posted by DanielRadcliffeIsSEXY Jul 15th 2007

James_Padfoot: Lemme guess. It's Ron and Hermione making out. Or it's Harry and Ginny making out! Which one?


Posted by SaphyreRavenclaw Jul 15th 2007

I HAVE FOUND THE REASON THAT THE FOLLOWING SITE CANNOT BE REAL.--->http://simm ysim.livejournal. com/471641 .html


Posted by DondaLonda Jul 15th 2007

Ok, so I won't read it, and I haven't read any of the comments, but does anyone remember MuggleNet making a statement that they'd be spoiler-free. Despite putting a little security on this article, still, it's a potential spoiler; they said they'd be spoiler-free. I think, report about it, link to it, but don't actually put the spoiler on the web-site.


Posted by kingsholto Jul 15th 2007

its not a real exerpt...J.K. would not have written "replied Snape". She would have had the other person say his name..or described him so we would know....though for the rest i do not know


Posted by wandless Jul 15th 2007

I'm not going to read it until it's official. I won't read ANY possible spoilers, real or fake, unless released by JK Rowling. And that definitely includes this one! If she was going to give us text from DH wouldn't she have released it from her website like she usually does? It's all a bit fishy...


Posted by Padfoots_miska Jul 15th 2007

not the most revealing first few lines... i'm skeptical. it's funny, because i was just thinking about how on earth DH could start, and then i checked mugglenet... BAM. EXCITEMENT


Posted by PirateEmery Jul 15th 2007

Fishy indeed... Just remember to take every bit of spoiler with a grain of salt. This time next week, we'll be done with the book and it'll all be over.


Posted by Ravleen Jul 15th 2007

This "trailer" that supposedly shows the manuscript, is it even out? Did the Guardian get to see it? It's all hazy.


Posted by slickstickers Jul 15th 2007

THE SCANS ARE FAKE 1) Notice how the flaps of the book jacket are very sleek and shiny. This looks very much like lamination or photoshop. 2) The translucence of the pages aren't realistic. Some of the text is bleeding through the page WAY too much while some isn't showing through at all. 3) One photo of a page of chapter titles looks extremely fake. Towards the bottom both pages of the alleged book bend outwards. The shadow towards the center of the book also looks very fake. 4) The Epilogue is titled differently in the contents and in the actual chapter, and the book has 784 pages. The scanned epilogue ends well below that number. In extent, only a handful of characters appear in the epilogue, while Jo has said that we will learn about a lot of the survivors. 5) The page after the contents page should be a page of harlequin pattern. This page is apparently missing in the scans. 6) Some of the scans show the back cover of the book behind the pages while others only show the pages. This clearly means that they were photoshopped. There are MANY other facts that point to these scans being fake. The first chapter may be authentic, but I would SERIOUSLY take these alleged spoilers with a grain (or an entire shaker) of salt.


Posted by Wheres_My_Snare Jul 15th 2007

I don't think the link is real, if you had the misfortune of looking at the scans notice a few things: The color tone indicates that these pages were scanned on a black and white copier, however the color of the jacket is bright and vivid. Questionable. Also, from what I've seen of the alleged chapter titles there are at least 2 character names that we've NEVER seen and if I'm not mistaken JKR stated that we wouldn't be meeting any new characters. I hope to goodness this isn't real. I wouldn't have a reason to believe it myself if it weren't for the danged artwork.


Posted by lostjunkie Jul 15th 2007

I'm so convinced all those scans are real oh my goodness i need the flash thingy they use in Men in Black now. D:


Posted by dont_look_down Jul 15th 2007

You never know, this could be real. After all, we did get a spoiler for Order of the Phoenix remember? And that was weeks or months before the release. BUT one thing that makes me skeptical is this: Instead of Snape replying "The best", wouldnt he have replied "The best, my lord". If he is evil then he would address Voldemort (if that is Voldemort in the excerpt) as my lord or whatever the death eaters call him, AND if he's good then he would do it anyway, as he would be faking being one of his followers. Does that make sense? Cant wait for the book!


Posted by gryff_tonks Jul 15th 2007

WOW. I dunno if I should believe or not believe. Anyone could have wrote that, it just doesn't, as others have stated, seem like JO's style. If it is indeed a passage from DH, I cannot wait to read more. If not, which I am leaning towards, the person who wrote it, has no life.


Posted by Tanderous Jul 15th 2007

It's so painfully obvious it's fake. In the first chapter she never goes by someones last name. There is always someowhat of a small introduction.


Posted by Loutre Jul 15th 2007

I "did the math" but that doesn't change the fact that the pictures I saw were pretty convincing, and only 4 or 5 pages long, with a pretty clear cut ending to the epilogue. Which is why I really hope the pictures I saw were wrong - if someone can prove the epilogue is actually more than 4 pages, everything else was a lie too and I can sleep easy.


Posted by PirateEmery Jul 15th 2007

Wheres_my_Snare gets bonus points from Pirate. The Sleuth of the Day title goes to you! Some bloke got the title yesterday for discovering an unitalicized spell in a scanned page, thus proving it to be a fake.




Wait! View more news stories in our News Archive.




Translate


MuggleNet is an unofficial Harry Potter fan site. Please email us if you have any questions or concerns. MuggleNet's original layouts were designed and created by Navy. All subsequent layouts by Dylan Spartz.

© 1999-2009 MuggleNet.com. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy | COPPA Policy | Feedback | Credits
Random Addresses

996 muggles currently online







Poll
Is Dumbledore right that Hogwarts sorts its students into Houses too soon - while the kids are too young?

Updates
Today's Updates
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 15]
Recent Updates
· Updated the Half-Blood Prince DVD info page [November 10]
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 8]
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 1]
Mail

Quotes
I don't know who Maxime thinks she's kidding. If Hagrid's half-giant, she definately is. Big bones... the only thing that's got bigger bones than her is a dinosaur.

Harry Potter
Goblet of Fire, Chapter 23, Page 430

See Another Quote
Big News
(10/01) - Happy 10th Birthday, MuggleNet!
(9/30) - HBP breaks $300 million mark in US
(9/25) - JK Rowling is now a Twitter user!
(9/17) - SS and COS Ultimate Editions arriving December 8th too
(9/17) - HBP DVD to hit U.S. stores on December 8
(9/15) - Wizarding World to open Spring 2010, rides confirmed
Release Dates
The Exhibition,
Boston opening:

October 25th, 2009
Half-Blood Prince DVD:
December 8th, 2009
Wizarding World:
Spring 2010
Deathly Hallows, Pt 1:
November 19th, 2010
Deathly Hallows, Pt 2:
July 15th, 2011

Advertisement