Scholastic gets subpoena to identify spoiler
Scholastic gets subpoena to identify spoiler The LA Times is reporting that the US Harry Potter publisher obtained a subpoena to learn the identity of a user who allegedly posted copies of Deathly Hallows on a California website.

Scholastic said in a court filing Monday that "materials hosted on Photobucket.com's system" contain materials that infringe copyrights owned by Scholastic and J.K. Rowling, author of the Harry Potter books. Photobucket.com, a News Corp. unit, is a website for sharing photos and videos on social networks such as MySpace.

The subpoena was sent to Gaia Interactive Inc. in San Jose seeking the identity of a user on gaiaonline.com, a social network, according to the filing in San Francisco federal court.

Gaia complied with the subpoena, removed the material and temporarily banned the user from the site, said Gaia spokesman Bill Danon.
Posted by Ciaran on Jul 17th | 1252 Comments
Visitor Comments
Posted by MissMalfoy Jul 17th 2007

hey people guess what i have this theory. the guy who posted the spoilers got banned from a site because he breached copyright, which is FRAUD. if the spoilers were actually REAL, don't you think that the guy would be arrested for actually having the book in the first place, never mind uploading it onto a site! because the police would want to know where he got the book from in the first place.


Posted by Gryffinclaw Jul 17th 2007

Anyone can have access to the picture of the cover put up by every Potter fansite. You can print it. Secondly the font the books is typed in could be duplicated. Now I believe they could be real but I think some people just were to bored and wrote there own story based on the ideas proposed by the millions of fans. Come on all of the proof doesnt add up. HP&DH is 784 pages long anot 759 like in the spoiler. Secondly the epiolouge didnt talk about any other except a few. Plus the death doesnt add up cause that person is alive in the epilogue. Yes, the people who did this have to much time, and also didnt think they could get in treouble but its plagaerism and the broke copyright law. so all of you asking why would the companies go after them if it wasnt real is cause its illegal.


Posted by be_ach Jul 17th 2007

xunkn0wndr3amx- that one is iffy, because from what i gather there are contradictions. Such as what you heard being mentioned, but then that person being mentioned in the epolauge as well. Sorry if that didnt make sence, i was trying to stay spoiler free. hats more or less the only one i heard too, and i agree, that would suck.


Posted by hpgirl21053 Jul 17th 2007

BELLA KILLS JERKYHOLE AND THEN RON KILLS BELLA WITH AN ALARM CLOCK FORMED LIKE A CHEESECAKE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !


Posted by hp_rox_my_sox15 Jul 17th 2007

jerkyhole..........you better be lying!!!!!!!!


Posted by sarahL Jul 17th 2007

wow jerkyhole2 thats great. you a-hole.


Posted by ukhazard Jul 17th 2007

Something to think about for the page counters. The US and UK editions have always had different numbers of pages...


Posted by 7_21_07 Jul 17th 2007

I'm thinking it might be a spoiler too.... I mean come on, how come Harry named his child Hugo? Where'd HUGO come from? Maybe he's really fat or something. But seriously, HUGO?


Posted by taylor77139 Jul 17th 2007

i have no clue how i am going to stay spoiler free until friday night but i am sure gonna try..


Posted by MissMalfoy Jul 17th 2007

okay jerkyhole you are not entitled to even LOOK at a cheesecake. EVER.


Posted by Gryffinclaw Jul 17th 2007

ukhazard your absolutly right, except that the uk version is 608 pages still not 759. just something to think about


Posted by jerkyhole Jul 17th 2007

BELLATRIX KILLS RON, NEVILLE KILLS BELLA, VOLDY KILLS SNAPE, PERCY AND LUPIN DIE, HARRY KILLS VOLDEMORT! ENJOY YOUR FA.GGOT BOOK NOW!!!! HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHA HAHAHAHAHAH


Posted by plever01 Jul 17th 2007

please, folks. Think about it: The scans may very well have been real, but the chapter summaries were probably a lot of horse puckey. The chapter titles hardly reveal anything about the plot until the book is read and the artwork for the chapters is more confusing than anything until you read the book. It hasn't been spoiled even for those who saw the scans. I repeat: Unless they had scans of the whole book and you're sure it was legit, you haven't been spoiled. Chapter titles reveal very little with JKR.


Posted by hpgirl21053 Jul 17th 2007

i am just ready to open some cheesecake whoop a** with bellatrix on jerkyhole!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Posted by sarahL Jul 17th 2007

lmao i agree with tabitto :P and jerkhole . well good for you . cuz that's prob wrong , but yeha we all know that Harry will kill Voldermort! yes. But yeah if it is true then ur a real a-hole arent yah


Posted by dumbledork62442 Jul 17th 2007

TAYLOR77139! If you wanna stay spoiler free like some of my friends then just stay off all HP sites, and all other major sites like Youtube, and Myspace. Basically stay away from any site that allows users to post comments because HP is such a big thing people will be leaving spoilers in all types of places you would never expect to see them.


Posted by harry_p_7 Jul 17th 2007

i agree with miss malfoy, that makes sense, he would have been arrested!! for 1- for taking the book ~ and with all this security he would have gotten in HUGE trouble. and 2- they did it b/c its fake and its becoming so real. besides, millions of ter sites have posted the exact same thing. so why wouldnt they get them if it was really real? hhhmmm?? see it must have been fae at least some of it, maybe their first chapter was real, but not the rest. *takes deep breath* i think i can finally breath... *looks at countdown and shrieks* OMFG 3 MORE DAYS!!! *faints* (i dont think ill be brething for a while. lol)


Posted by MissMalfoy Jul 17th 2007

JERKYHOLE are you absolutely dumb? nobody cares about ur fake spoilers. cheesecakes will defeat you. okay.


Posted by hpgirl21053 Jul 17th 2007

oh, and jerkyhole, u actually are gonna make us enjoy the book, b/c what u r saying is making us want to read it even more, so we can find out the truth for ourselves.......i bet u will have a dream about cheesecakes one day, and then u will go in ur kitchen and eat some and realize that they were poisoned and die.....all thnx to bellatrix.....it will be a funny death i can expect...... BELLA KILLS JERKYHOLE WITH A CHEESECAKE


Posted by rob15 Jul 17th 2007

I AM GOING TO COME OVER THERE JERKYFAG LIKE JACKIE CHAN AND SHHOVE A BOOK UP YOUR FLIPPIN A$$ AND EAT CHEESECAKE WHILE YOU SQUEAL LIKE A WEASEL FOR YOUR MAMMA AND I WILL LAUGH, HOUSIFA DIRTBURGLAR!!!


Posted by dumbledork62442 Jul 17th 2007

How can they arrest the guy when they don't even know who he is? Don't you understand what the subpoena was for? Scholastic is trying to figure out he he is and they are subpoenaing the site to get that information.


Posted by MissMalfoy Jul 17th 2007

everybody calm down, in 3 days you'll find out everything. but trust me that the majority and if not all of these "spoilers" are fake. :)


Posted by bookaholic Jul 17th 2007

I don't know about the rest of the spoilers, but the epilogue is fake, fake, fake. Most of the reasons this is true have already been mentioned, but also notice that the American versions never leave entirely blank pages between chapters. Especially not blank pages covered with suspicious diamond patterns. The epilogue should have started on the page on the left. It didn't. So yes, there's a reason it isn't at JKR's writing level...


Posted by plever01 Jul 17th 2007

bookaholic: do you consume bookahol? and if so, where can i find it? It sounds nice.


Posted by ScienceNerd51 Jul 17th 2007

Why do people bother ruining books for people? It's a very evil practical joke. >P Thank god I didn't see that spoiler. I'm on Gaia all the time (Gaia absolutely rocks, btw. ;) )


Posted by dumbledork62442 Jul 17th 2007

bookaholic I also agree that the epilogue is fake but not for the same reasons as you. You have to remember, we've never had an epilogue or a preclude in any of the past HP books so we don't know exactly how they'd go about it. I think it's fake because it doesn't sound like JKR, is too short, and only tells us about the lives of a hand full of characters


Posted by pline Jul 17th 2007

i was hoping to see any news about this posted here, but since i couldnt i will post a comment :) apparently boxes of HP7 were opened in China! picture: http://img527.imageshac k.us/img527/4210/11846515 01876ah7.jpg I dont know if its true, but there are loads of brazilian websites posting the book translated in portuguese...it seems like the real book. I didnt read it, but friends of mine did and they say it seems right. That is so not fair...


Posted by rob15 Jul 17th 2007

JERKYFAG-HOLE, OR HOUSIFA DIRTBURGLAR, YOU AND YOUR DEATH AGGIES WILL ONE DAY DIE FROM THE ALMIGHTY WARRIOR PC MASTER YUNGCHEESECAKE AND WE WILL LAUGH AS YOU SQUIRM LIKE RATS WHILE WE EAT CHEESECAKE IN FRONT OF YOU AND YOU WILL REALIZE HOW EVIL AND UNCHEESECAKEY YOU ARE AND YOU WILL THINK, R.A.B. ACTUALLY STANDS FOR RADCLIFFE ACTUALLY BARFS!!!


Posted by hpgirl21053 Jul 17th 2007

ok, i am out, but my cheesecakeness will be back!!! Lata's!!!!!


Posted by This_End_Up Jul 17th 2007

Between the cheesecake insanity and the spoiler-happy folks at this website.....some of you guys need to just sleep until 11:59 pm on friday. I can has cheezecake now plz?


Posted by dumbledork62442 Jul 17th 2007

I meant prologue, I don't know why I wrote preclude =]]


Posted by jb1 Jul 17th 2007

I HAVE ONE THING TO SAY Cheesecake>Jerkyho le Lmao how sad do you have to be to come on here and try and annoy people by posting spoilers? Jerkyhole, dude, just get a life. And regarding the 'spoilers', i think they are fake tbh. They dont have to be real to breach copyright (as many people have said). Also, there are lots of descrepencies, which pretty much confirms they are fake for me. Anyway, just three days left guys... Wait... i said 3 things, oh well


Posted by JPN001 Jul 17th 2007

Well I did not intend to post again on copyright law, but I must disabuse some of you of your mistaken notions. First, copyright violation is not fraud. Passing off a pirated copy as real may be fraud, but copyright infringement under Title 17 of the US Code (and also under British law, although on this I have little training) is not fraud. And even if criminal copyright infringement charges would be appropriate, which as I indicated before is unlikely in this type of infringement case, they still have to identify the perpetrator before arresting him/her, which is the purpose of the subpoena, to get records by which he/she can be identified. Now, if they can prove that the person stole the book from a distributor, shipping company, bookstore, etc., then the person may be arrested for petty larceny, although I doubt even that would happen. I don’t mean to be rude, but you people are delusional (to use Emerson’s favorite word, although it is not completely apropos to the matter at hand), if you believe the lack of an arrest (for what is likely a civil, not criminal matter) is evidence that the images are not authentic. The only proof either way will come from an authoritative source, such as the publisher, the author or the book when we all get it on July 21.


Posted by Belsito Jul 17th 2007

I don't know what's ticking me off the most at the moment - the FAKE spoilers or all the CHEESECAKE comments. They're just about as humorous as carpet pile.


Posted by SnapeKillsKira Jul 17th 2007

OK....The cheesecake thing's just getting dumb now. I read something in the 'false' DH....................... ......................... ......................... ......................... ......................... ......................... ....SPOILERMEGAMAYBESPOIL ERS?!?! about a "resurrection stone"......maybe the death DOES add up, if this resurrection stone works how I think it does ENDSPOILERMEGAMAYBESPOILE R??? And yes, jerkyhole. We know. Go home now.


Posted by rob15 Jul 17th 2007

THIS_END_UP: to become a fellow cheesecakeian you must recite the Cheeesecakeian Oath: I promise to eat cheesecake every day, I will not read spoilers, I will fetch Rob15 cheeesecake when he asks, And I will fight to destroy the mighty Housifa Dirtburglar and his Death Aggies


Posted by Trunks2598 Jul 17th 2007

like the guy said before me, you guys are hilariously in denial. some of your comments attempting to prove the spoilers false is absolutely hilarious. they are most likely real. you read it despite the giant red warning letter. you got owned.


Posted by DumbledoresArmy707 Jul 17th 2007

We hate u jerkyhole!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!


Posted by omghydeme Jul 17th 2007

Wow, I'm a member of Gaia and I didn't even know that. DX *doesn't want to be spoiled*


Posted by xunkn0wndr3amx Jul 17th 2007

thanks be_ach for answering I heard about that contradiction but do you think that this information that jerkyhole keeps spreading is the information that mugglenet is talking about in the post??


Posted by dumbledork62442 Jul 17th 2007

THANK YOU JPN001! The people on here really need to inform themselves about the law.


Posted by Patronus09321 Jul 17th 2007

Can someone post the link? THe link is broken and I want to see what it says!


Posted by GodricsHollow5 Jul 17th 2007

Ok, here is what I do not understand. I saw this spoiler it says Ron dies, yet on the last page of the book- Ron is at the train station 19 years later. I don't get it...


Posted by hpandme Jul 17th 2007

lmao. why in god's green earth would harry name his child hugo. that just does it for me lol! CHEEECAKE. the biggest inside joke in the world.


Posted by randyw Jul 17th 2007

For me the book is not spoiled even though I have read some of the "spoilers", temptation was to great. All the spoiler pages are different. Also, they are several different endings to the book out there that I have heard about. And If somebody can post something they do which everybody thinks is true it will make there day. Unless you got a copy in your hands you do not know if anything out there is true or not, so as I long as i do not know tthe truth then the book is not spoiled


Posted by tylermiller Jul 17th 2007

I am so dissapointed! I read the chapter titles and a bit of the last chapter! The ending was stupid and it is unfortunate that 10 years of genius ends with that unsatisfying excuse for the conclusion to a saga!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!


Posted by This_End_Up Jul 17th 2007

Gah. Scholastic should just admit to allowing the book to be leaked, regardless of the fact that ELEVENTY BILLION DOLLARS was spent SPECIFICALLY to keep this from happening. "Yep, book's out, sorry everyone, we suck" should suffice in a press release, I think. "Like Voldemort, we were pwned by a young man with wit and will." Nah, i'll pass on the cheesecakeian thing, thanks anyway, Rob15. Sounds like too much of a commitment. I still think the epilogue is fake. At least I hope it is.....


Posted by GASP Jul 17th 2007

From gaia? Not surprised.XD If you don't want to be spoiled it's best not to go into any forums or spoiler sites. I mean, the people on gaia are kind of looking to ruin it for people. It's your own fault if you let them.


Posted by dumbledork62442 Jul 17th 2007

GodricsHollow5, a lot of websites are posting multiple spoilers so they don't all add up, but I will I think the epilogue is fake.


Posted by CosChris Jul 17th 2007

I was shown the first page of a spoiler with the entire book. It is a bunch of pictures with a person standing there turning each page. I am glad all I saw was the table of contents. The lack of respect for the people who want to read the book when it comes out, the devoted fans who have grown up waiting for the next Harry Potter book is disgusting. Scholastic should take every legal action and I hope that any user who puts up spoilers will be prosecuted. So, for those of us patiently waiting, 3 more days. Good luck on avoiding slips of the tongue from not-so-patient friends willing to give away the end of the series.




Wait! View more news stories in our News Archive.




Translate


MuggleNet is an unofficial Harry Potter fan site. Please email us if you have any questions or concerns. MuggleNet's original layouts were designed and created by Navy. All subsequent layouts by Dylan Spartz.

© 1999-2009 MuggleNet.com. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy | COPPA Policy | Feedback | Credits
Random Addresses

904 muggles currently online







Poll
Is Dumbledore right that Hogwarts sorts its students into Houses too soon - while the kids are too young?

Updates
Today's Updates
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 15]
Recent Updates
· Updated the Half-Blood Prince DVD info page [November 10]
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 8]
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 1]
Mail

Quotes
Poor old Snuffles. He must really like you Harry... imagine having to live off rats.

Ron Weasley
Goblet of Fire, Chapter 27, Page 534

See Another Quote
Big News
(10/01) - Happy 10th Birthday, MuggleNet!
(9/30) - HBP breaks $300 million mark in US
(9/25) - JK Rowling is now a Twitter user!
(9/17) - SS and COS Ultimate Editions arriving December 8th too
(9/17) - HBP DVD to hit U.S. stores on December 8
(9/15) - Wizarding World to open Spring 2010, rides confirmed
Release Dates
The Exhibition,
Boston opening:

October 25th, 2009
Half-Blood Prince DVD:
December 8th, 2009
Wizarding World:
Spring 2010
Deathly Hallows, Pt 1:
November 19th, 2010
Deathly Hallows, Pt 2:
July 15th, 2011

Advertisement