Rowling, WB file suit over companion book
Rowling, WB file suit over companion book J.K. Rowling updated the News Section of her official site earlier today saying that she could not approve of "companion books" or "encyclopedias" to her series.

The Harry Potter author and Warner Bros. filed suit in a Manhattan Court today against Harry Potter Lexicon owner Steve Vander Ark and several defendants for publishing "an unofficial encyclopedic companion to the 'Harry Potter' series," saying it "infringes copyright and attempts to cash in on the successful brand." The Harry Potter Lexicon is slated to be released by RDR Books on November 28.

Roger Rapoport, the publisher and owner of RDR Books said the companion novel "only promotes the sale of J.K. Rowling's work and we intend to publish on schedule as planned."

Thanks to everyone who sent this in!
Posted by Micah on Oct 31st | 718 Comments
Visitor Comments
Posted by i_loverz_HP Nov 1st 2007

danny wanna fight.


Posted by dannyrob15 Nov 1st 2007

muhaha it will never end...never....ever...oh i'm about to pass out again, its 11:05.


Posted by honeydukes0209 Nov 1st 2007

haha...i'm gonna have a million nicknames soon enough..eek...aren't you tired? i still have so much hw...aughgh...hey loverz!


Posted by dannyrob15 Nov 1st 2007

lets go alizzle...u don't wanna mess wit d-rob!


Posted by i_loverz_HP Nov 1st 2007

OMG WHERE IS EVERYBODY IM GETTING PISSED!!


Posted by dannyrob15 Nov 1st 2007

ah shiznits i have to go...bout to get kicked off by dad. bye! i just sent you both about a bijillion emails...


Posted by honeydukes0209 Nov 1st 2007

:) bye danny...hey loverz..whats up?


Posted by i_loverz_HP Nov 1st 2007

hey honey bunches of oats whats craken my neazzzy? bye danizzle tell ur father i said holler boller. lol.


Posted by honeydukes0209 Nov 1st 2007

:) hey! ahh..nothing much...it's 10:31 pm..and still got lotssa hw...:(...you??


Posted by i_loverz_HP Nov 1st 2007

not much bored out my freakin mind.....im going crazy lol. what kinda hw do u have?


Posted by honeydukes0209 Nov 1st 2007

i'm in IB so, it's ALOT every day...gr...let's see, today i had to study for 3 tests, do 14 questions, 14 vocab, read 50 pages....do a math review...(you know about my math crisis right?) i'm failng right now, and if i don't get an A on my geometry test tmrw...i *gulp*...pretty much fail and is DEAD. please wish me luck tomorrow! this weekend's gonna be jam-packed...i have 2 essays...a math project, regular math hw, maps, read 60 pages of novel, questions, vocab.....i hate IB!!!


Posted by honeydukes0209 Nov 1st 2007

bye then loverz! goodnight, see ya tmrw.:)


Posted by Wand Nov 2nd 2007

This has made me INCREDIBLY ANGRY and losing respect for Jo. I now see she HAS been in it for money just4 as much as "for the fans" wasn't Jo giving lexicon a fan site award saying something along the lines of... If it wasn't for hp lexicon she'd have to go look at all the books again, and that this made her process of writing the book easier? the hp lexicon was like a godsend... these people spent years making it all about harry pot5ter, they dedicated time because they were passionate about the books they felt that hp needed a lexicon. You are writing an ecyclopedia of all the information you haven't previously disclosed so write about that!!! lexicon is awesome you should PAY THEM not SEU THEM... for all the hard work they've done, how awesome the website looks. YOU'RE AN IDIOT!!!! Just wanting more money. I am angry at you..... So disappointed. This isn't Laura Malory.. this is REAL.


Posted by poofer Nov 2nd 2007

Someone forgot their roots and only cares about money... Go Lexicon.


Posted by waterpgirl4 Nov 2nd 2007

All these people who are angry at Jo, it is just kinda funny. They are HER characters. Period. She has every right to decide what, and when things get published, and who cares if she is doing it for the extra money they are her books. Lexicon is a great site but all the stuff they write on that site is technically hers. So maybe the owner of Lexicon should write their own book instead of cashing in on other peoples ideas.


Posted by EowynRowena Nov 2nd 2007

Wow. I must admit, this kind of disappoints me. It's a fan book! I highly doubt these guys wrote it for the money. Go Steve, I'm behind you! And hey, what does that mean for the ominous companion book Emerson and Ben wrote?


Posted by Nimue Nov 2nd 2007

Huh. I've got to read around about this, because I'm not sure what the difference is between Vander Ark publishing his stuff, and all the other 'unofficial guides' which have come out over the years. So long as he isn't quoting chunks of the books without permission, I fail to see the difference. Even so, what the heck is he playing at trying to get it published as a book? It's a wonderful free resource, it certainly sounds as though he's doing it for the money, much as I would like to think otherwise. I've heard him on Pottercast. I wonder if they'll drop him after this debacle.


Posted by rob1007 Nov 2nd 2007

hey cheesecakians!!!! i have to go to school now! at least its friday and i got to stay home yesterday


Posted by Die_Zimtzicke Nov 2nd 2007

There have been many unofficial guides and encyclopedias. Some have been sued. Some have not. But no one ever went to the news media and made a big whooping deal about those suits. Jo never singled those people out on her site. Some of them didn't get sued until after their books had been out for sale for some time. She is treating Steve DIFFERENTLY than she has treated others. That is why I'm not on her side, as much as I dislike the policies of the Lexicon forums.


Posted by lilbecky8 Nov 2nd 2007

morning cheesecakes!


Posted by princeofdarkness Nov 2nd 2007

doubleyou tee eff Jo!? wtf warner bros!?


Posted by HPfanx14 Nov 2nd 2007

morning becky, how are youu?


Posted by lilbecky8 Nov 2nd 2007

good good how about you?


Posted by HPfanx14 Nov 2nd 2007

blah im good. but i have to pick a busniess plan and i dont kno what to do!! ughh! help me :]


Posted by lilbecky8 Nov 2nd 2007

a business plan? do you have a few to pick from or do you have to make one up? what kind of things do you have to decide on?


Posted by HPfanx14 Nov 2nd 2007

like just what kind of business i want to start.. im seriouly considering starting a harry potter store business, which would be cool but idk bout that, but i was different ideas to fall back on just incase it wouldnt work, my friend catylin on the volleyball team said that not to do a resturant b/c its really hard.


Posted by lilbecky8 Nov 2nd 2007

ahhh ok... yeah a harry potter store would be cool!!! you would have harry potter costumes, wands, art work, decorative house things (book ends, lamps, figurines) jewelry. you could have a kid side where you have more toys and an adult side where you have more art and stuff like that.


Posted by HPfanx14 Nov 2nd 2007

mmmhmm. there is soo much i could put in my store, it would be soo easy to do the HPstore. im not sure what to call it tho.. i was thinking "Muggle World" .have any suggestions? lol


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

GOOD MORNING EVERYONE!!!!! no school today!! WHOOOO------April


Posted by HPfanx14 Nov 2nd 2007

heyy april! jealous, im in school. whts upp? and do you have in idea for a harry potter store name? i have to think of a business plan and i decided to make a harry potter store so i need a busniesss namee


Posted by lilbecky8 Nov 2nd 2007

or the Wonderful World of Harry Potter (i think thats what Universal is calling their land tho) umm let me think.... The Harry Potter Store, Muggle Mart (but that kind of sounds like its a grocery store) Wizards R Us, The Wizarding World store, All Things Magical. I dont know if any of those are any good.


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

I dunno, I suck at names lol:D The magical world of all things HP :D


Posted by Mrsroonil_wazlib Nov 2nd 2007

HOLA!!!!!!!!! wow i haven't really been on here much since the book release.....


Posted by HPfanx14 Nov 2nd 2007

im likin the Wizards R Us, but thats kind Toys R Us.. and you know what i could do!? i could have like sections in my store and for the food area i could call it Muggle Mart, and like say theres a section of books and calendars and wht not it could be called like Hogwarts Library :P


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

Bonjour!


Posted by Mrsroonil_wazlib Nov 2nd 2007

what about...Diagon Alley?nah...


Posted by lilbecky8 Nov 2nd 2007

tahts a really good idea Kayla! yeah have bertie botts and chocolate frogs and butter beer, that would so so cool. And then have different parts named different things (like muggle mart, hogwarts library) thats aweosme too!! you should have a joke part of it to, like weasley's wizarding wheezes


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

Yeah I like that idea better:D


Posted by lilbecky8 Nov 2nd 2007

hiya mrsroonil! how are you doing? long time no talk. :-)


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

Im sooo bored!!!


Posted by HPfanx14 Nov 2nd 2007

i like that Mrsroonil_wazlib! and have the clothing store (cant think of the name! ugh) . too bad someone does really make a store like this! it would be soo awesomee


Posted by Mrsroonil_wazlib Nov 2nd 2007

hello! im just starting to reread deathly hallows...i need to reread the chapter where harry dies but doesn't die because i still don't get it...


Posted by lilbecky8 Nov 2nd 2007

Wizarding Wears, Madam Kaylas Robes, play off of the stores that we already know of from HP


Posted by Quantummilkshake Nov 2nd 2007

The book Emerson/Ben/etc. wrote was PREDICTIONS and stuff NOT an encyclopedia... The Mugglenet book was there OPINIONS on what would happen in book 7 and thus, there work. The Lexicon book doesn't have any opinions. It's just a book about who does what in HP's world. And for anyone who still sees it as unfair that they are getting sued: It's JK ROWLING'S BOOK. She THOUGHT up this stuff NOT HP Lexicon. They only wrote what she had already dreamed up in paragraph format. NONE of there own opinions were involved or anything, JUST WHAT SHE HAD ALREADY EXPRESSED. The way I see it is: Any fan has every right to dedicate as much time as they want to write stuff on the iinternet for people to view for free BUT no fan has the right to write about the books so they can sell it for there own gain. And if you've read, jkr can't be doing this for a profit BECAUSE all the money from the court case AND the encyclopedia she wanted to make are GOING TO CHARITY... Go to Leaky. They have this whole case up in incredible detail in a news article. Read the whole thing before you make up your mind. Warner bros. contacted lexicon about five times before they tried to sue.


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

Im hungry!!But theres nothing to eat for breakfast except for doughnuts EWWW


Posted by HPfanx14 Nov 2nd 2007

ahaha yah becky! im likin the Madam Kayla's Robes :P lol . and the he didnt die because he had two souls in him Mrsroonil_wazlib.. and when voldemort did that avavada kedavera, it killed the voldemorts soul, not harrys.


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

Yeah, but wasn't Harrys soul alreaddy killed by then? I dunno, its confusing


Posted by lilbecky8 Nov 2nd 2007

yeah i had to reread it again Mrsroonil before I fully understood what happened. YAY for Madam Kayla's Robes, Muggle Mart and rest of it!!! WHOO HOO!! You really need to open up a store like this, I would so be there. (I could do your marketing and advertising too!!)


Posted by Mrsroonil_wazlib Nov 2nd 2007

yeah i probably didn't get it cuz it was lik3 5:30


Posted by Mrsroonil_wazlib Nov 2nd 2007

yeah i probably didn't get it cuz it was lik3 5:30




Wait! View more news stories in our News Archive.




Translate


MuggleNet is an unofficial Harry Potter fan site. Please email us if you have any questions or concerns. MuggleNet's original layouts were designed and created by Navy. All subsequent layouts by Dylan Spartz.

© 1999-2009 MuggleNet.com. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy | COPPA Policy | Feedback | Credits
Random Addresses

704 muggles currently online







Poll
Is Dumbledore right that Hogwarts sorts its students into Houses too soon - while the kids are too young?

Updates
Today's Updates
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 15]
Recent Updates
· Updated the Half-Blood Prince DVD info page [November 10]
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 8]
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 1]
Mail

Quotes
Will you excuse me if I don't let you off homework today; I assure you that if you die, you need not hand it in.

Prof. McGonagall
Prisoner of Azkaban

See Another Quote
Big News
(10/01) - Happy 10th Birthday, MuggleNet!
(9/30) - HBP breaks $300 million mark in US
(9/25) - JK Rowling is now a Twitter user!
(9/17) - SS and COS Ultimate Editions arriving December 8th too
(9/17) - HBP DVD to hit U.S. stores on December 8
(9/15) - Wizarding World to open Spring 2010, rides confirmed
Release Dates
The Exhibition,
Boston opening:

October 25th, 2009
Half-Blood Prince DVD:
December 8th, 2009
Wizarding World:
Spring 2010
Deathly Hallows, Pt 1:
November 19th, 2010
Deathly Hallows, Pt 2:
July 15th, 2011

Advertisement