Rowling, WB file suit over companion book
Rowling, WB file suit over companion book J.K. Rowling updated the News Section of her official site earlier today saying that she could not approve of "companion books" or "encyclopedias" to her series.

The Harry Potter author and Warner Bros. filed suit in a Manhattan Court today against Harry Potter Lexicon owner Steve Vander Ark and several defendants for publishing "an unofficial encyclopedic companion to the 'Harry Potter' series," saying it "infringes copyright and attempts to cash in on the successful brand." The Harry Potter Lexicon is slated to be released by RDR Books on November 28.

Roger Rapoport, the publisher and owner of RDR Books said the companion novel "only promotes the sale of J.K. Rowling's work and we intend to publish on schedule as planned."

Thanks to everyone who sent this in!
Posted by Micah on Oct 31st | 718 Comments
Visitor Comments
Posted by HPfanx14 Nov 2nd 2007

well im not REALLY making a store like this, i just have to come up with an idea for a busniesss and act like its real and figure out everything that would involve my busienss. and i would prolly have to figure out advertising and marketing and what not. If i do become and entrepreneur i would be an awesome business to start, but im not sure if that;s what i want to do yet.. ugh taklin about the future is scary. lol


Posted by Mrsroonil_wazlib Nov 2nd 2007

oops-what i meant to say was i probably didn't get it because it was 5:30 AM and i was half asleep


Posted by lilbecky8 Nov 2nd 2007

April, Harry had his soul and a piece of voldy's soul in him when he went into the forest to face Voldy. When Voldy casted Avedra Kedvra on Harry, Voldy killed the piece of his soul in Harry and Harry's blood in Voldy saved Harry from dying. That is why they were both knocked to the ground and both lived. the piece of soul from the other saved them, but that connection was destroyed. And becuz harry willing scarificed himself for the rest of the wizarding world, they were all protected by the same charm that Lily set up Harry when she died for him. That is why Harry could be Cruicioed and not feel it and the spells werent hurting the other members of the Order.


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

I HATE ENTREPRANEURS!! jk jk. NO its cos we're learnig bout them in US history and economics, and we're doing the stupidest project now ARGHH


Posted by sillyme Nov 2nd 2007

can i join this cheesecakian club? how do i?


Posted by HPfanx14 Nov 2nd 2007

yah, i still dont get the part wht Harry was being cursed but it didnt effect him?? and lol april, im learning to become one. which is ohk but its gets frustrating.


Posted by lilbecky8 Nov 2nd 2007

sillyme, yeah you can join the cheesecakians, but you have to take an oath and only a wise one can give it to you. our wiseones are Dannyrob, Sirius_lee (Ari) and Hallowsaint. Ari should probably be on sometime today, so just keep an eye out for her. Kayla, if you need any ideas for advertising or marketing for your project let me know, thats what i do for a living. yes thinking of the future is scary. yikes, i still dont wanna grow up and still am not positive on what i want to do for a living. hahahahaha


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

lol. Yeah silly me, Ari still sleeping, but shell probably be awake in a nour or 2 lol


Posted by HPfanx14 Nov 2nd 2007

well its lunch time and i gotta go. peace!


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

See ya! Imma go eat too . ILL BE BACK


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

Imma back!! but I gotta og in like 2 mins cos i need to pick up my baby bro from school!:D


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

Imma back!! but I gotta og in like 2 mins cos i need to pick up my baby bro from school!:D


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

Imma back!! but I gotta og in like 2 mins cos i need to pick up my baby bro from school!:D


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

Imma back!! but I gotta og in like 2 mins cos i need to pick up my baby bro from school!:D


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

Imma back!! but I gotta og in like 2 mins cos i need to pick up my baby bro from school!:D


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

Imma back!! but I gotta og in like 2 mins cos i need to pick up my baby bro from school!:D


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

Imma back!! but I gotta og in like 2 mins cos i need to pick up my baby bro from school!:D


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

Imma back!! but I gotta og in like 2 mins cos i need to pick up my baby bro from school!:D


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

Imma back!! but I gotta og in like 2 mins cos i need to pick up my baby bro from school!:D


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

Imma back!! but I gotta og in like 2 mins cos i need to pick up my baby bro from school!:D


Posted by lilbecky8 Nov 2nd 2007

holy crap April! thats a lot of comments!


Posted by nomarscharm5 Nov 2nd 2007

We should get TEAM JO/ TEAM STEVE shirts.


Posted by crookshanks9 Nov 2nd 2007

She's such a girl. She really needs to stop suing people for ridiculous reasons and get over herself.


Posted by julietsurvives Nov 2nd 2007

Just for anyone who is uneducated: Publishing a book that contains copyright information that does not belong to the author or publishers is illegal. What the Lexicon is doing is making money off of Jo's work, as is stated in the article. Anyone who tries to parallel what the Lexicon is doing and what Mugglenet did should stop and think. Mugglenet published a book on theories - what they thought might happen in the seventh book. It wasn't a companion book, nor did it take all the information we have received from Jo or any other official sources and produce a reference for the author's work (regardless of it being "official" or "unofficial").


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

wtf is wrong with april that effing apammer!!! grrr *slaps april a she walks by with her stench* hey guys ARIS HERE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11 no school ppl!!! :D :D


Posted by AbyBlutjager Nov 2nd 2007

Well, I guess I shouldn't go ahead with the encyclopedia I was planning.... Mine was going to be analytical, not like I'm writing with her knowledge, just as someone analizing the serties.... Anyway, I think I'll just sratch the idea. This suggests something important, though. She probably wouldn't sue over this issue if she had no plans to write the encyclopedia herself. Looks like she plans to write it! Yeah.


Posted by MissMalfoy Nov 2nd 2007

Heya, any cheesecakians here yet?


Posted by Marie_Lee Nov 2nd 2007

hi!! i ma!! :D well actually i havve to go. take a shower but ill be back kkk peace!


Posted by AcidPops33 Nov 2nd 2007

*Wonders if anyone is here yet*


Posted by Ranger Nov 2nd 2007

STARTING A BUSINESS OR SOMETHING???---I DID NOT READ THE THREAD--BUT IF SO, CHECK OUT LEGALZOOM DOT COM FOR DISCOUNTS ON PAPER WORK ETC.....SEE IF THE WILL HELP OUT


Posted by AcidPops33 Nov 2nd 2007

Lol ooooooookaaaaaaay then Ranger... O.o Gotta go, if anyone is there... be on later.


Posted by BatJeff Nov 2nd 2007

On the one hand , I kind of find it petty of JK Rowling to sue these guys about their book. Couldn't she just have been like: "Hey... please don't publish that?" But apparently not... But not to talk down to my favourite writer ever! These guys from the Lexicon site... why didn't they just ask Jo's permission to make the encyclopedia... and possibly work WITH her to make it. That way, everything would be canon, and it would have been awesome. Also... does this mean she is not making an encyclopedia about the Harry Potter Universe? Because I really hope she does. No sure why the guys at Lexicon didn't just ask Jo's permission... but... whatever I guess.


Posted by EowynRowena Nov 2nd 2007

Nomarscharm5, I agree, we really should get shirts ;)


Posted by kaze_ Nov 2nd 2007

Why do they feel the need to publish the encyclopedia anyway? We've got the site, that's all we need. Yeah, sorry, but I'm with Jo on this one. If I were her, I'd be flattered, sure, but I'd still feel a little possessive of the series and the characters, quite honestly. They are, after all, a big part of her life.


Posted by jen04 Nov 2nd 2007

I have a question, in my library of all things Potter, I have a book called "The Harry Potter Companion" by Acascias Riphouse. Why have I not heard about a lawsuit involving this book/author?


Posted by darkveils5 Nov 2nd 2007

Wow, I think she is being kind of petty. The lexicon only posts known facts about the book. I mean she even awarded it on her sight. First she sues that Indian community for a Hogwarts display and now she is suing the Lexicon. Who knows maybe she'll sue Emerson next for Mugglenet. And other people have written and published books and guides about Harry Potter, why is this so different?


Posted by HarryandGinnyforlife Nov 2nd 2007

Personally, I think Jo is perfectly justified in doing this. If I were going to release an encyclopedia about an entire book series I created, I wouldn't want someone else to do the same thing, let alone without my permission. And to anyone who says she's "in it for the money" or anything like that: have you been living in a cave? Jo's donated to countless charities, she's the spokesperson for a charity, and I'm pretty sure she started her own (either that or she funds it). When she adopted a dog, she gave a personal one thousand dollar check to the shelter. For years she's auctioned off her books for charity, and she's doing the same thing with "The Tales of Beedle the Bard." Does that sound like she just wants money?


Posted by goldfish Nov 2nd 2007

Gah, I am SO annoyed after reading some of the comments people have made against JKR. She has EVERY right to sue for this. To all of those people who keep calling her greedy or money-minded, you seem to have this completely backwards! It is this STEVE person who is selling HER work in order to make money for himself. If his sole intention was just to provide a nice source of HP information for the fans, he has his website for that- a website Jo has endorsed. Instead, he is attempting to make money by publishing a book that basically just recycles JKR's ideas/characters/world. Also, this is a clear case of plagarism (which is illegal, btw... this person is breaking the law here), as JKR has ALREADY published Fantastic Beasts... and Quidditch Through the Ages, which present aspects of the HP world in a textbook/encyclopedic-typ e manner. Add in the fact that Jo has said many times that she intends to publish a full encylopedia of the HP world (for which the money would go to CHARITY, not her own pockets as is the case for Steve's book), and it's pretty obvious that this guy is stealing her work for his own profit. I assume that a lot of the people claiming Jo is doing this to be mean or whatever are young or something, and don't understand what plagarism is. In that case, let me present this example to you: If you worked really really hard and wrote an essay for school, and then one of your classmates took your paper and rewrote it and turned it in as their own work, they would obviously be cheating, right? Getting a grade which they don't deserve, because they handed in work that wasn't their own? This is the same thing, people. This guy is taking her work, re-formating it, and trying to make money off of it. It's cheating, stealing... and I commend JKR for having the guts to stand up to them. I'm sure it's been very hard for her. It reminds me of this line: "It takes a great deal of bravery to stand up to our enemies, but just as much to stand up to our friends....


Posted by SnapeFever911 Nov 2nd 2007

how rude of those people to write a unofficial book with out JKs permission i also want to be a cheesecakin


Posted by AcidPops33 Nov 2nd 2007

Anyone here?


Posted by SnapeFever911 Nov 2nd 2007

me


Posted by AcidPops33 Nov 2nd 2007

Hey SnapeFever! (Cool name!) What's up? Are you a Cheesecakeian?


Posted by SnapeFever911 Nov 2nd 2007

no im trying to be one but......


Posted by AcidPops33 Nov 2nd 2007

Lol You just have to wait for Ari or danny to come one. Or Hallowsaint, I guess, but I haven't seen him in a reaaaaaal long time..


Posted by SnapeFever911 Nov 2nd 2007

sorry my sis was reading the new news*sigh* i hate oder sister


Posted by AcidPops33 Nov 2nd 2007

Haha that's alright. I have an older brother and he's a real pain too.


Posted by honeydukes0209 Nov 2nd 2007

hey snapefever and acid! i'm honey btw...if you're looking for danny, and marie and grinds, they're on the post above this one! :)


Posted by SnapeFever911 Nov 2nd 2007

thanks!!!


Posted by AcidPops33 Nov 2nd 2007

Hey honey!! Oh wow, thanks a lot!!! :D SnapeFever; go to the post above this. That's where danny (dannyrob15) is, and he can make you a Cheesecakeian! :) See you there!


Posted by Belinda Nov 2nd 2007

I'm sorry, but I'm totally agreeing with Luke. What the heck is up with that?




Wait! View more news stories in our News Archive.




Translate


MuggleNet is an unofficial Harry Potter fan site. Please email us if you have any questions or concerns. MuggleNet's original layouts were designed and created by Navy. All subsequent layouts by Dylan Spartz.

© 1999-2009 MuggleNet.com. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy | COPPA Policy | Feedback | Credits
Random Addresses

719 muggles currently online







Poll
Is Dumbledore right that Hogwarts sorts its students into Houses too soon - while the kids are too young?

Updates
Today's Updates
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 15]
Recent Updates
· Updated the Half-Blood Prince DVD info page [November 10]
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 8]
· Updated Crazy Caption Contest [November 1]
Mail

Quotes
He therefore had to endure over an hour of Professor Trelawney, who spent half the lesson telling everyone that the position of Mars with relation to Saturn at that moment meant that people born in July were in great danger of sudden, violent deaths.

Goblet of Fire, Chapter 20, Page 345

See Another Quote
Big News
(10/01) - Happy 10th Birthday, MuggleNet!
(9/30) - HBP breaks $300 million mark in US
(9/25) - JK Rowling is now a Twitter user!
(9/17) - SS and COS Ultimate Editions arriving December 8th too
(9/17) - HBP DVD to hit U.S. stores on December 8
(9/15) - Wizarding World to open Spring 2010, rides confirmed
Release Dates
The Exhibition,
Boston opening:

October 25th, 2009
Half-Blood Prince DVD:
December 8th, 2009
Wizarding World:
Spring 2010
Deathly Hallows, Pt 1:
November 19th, 2010
Deathly Hallows, Pt 2:
July 15th, 2011

Advertisement