Doyle works magic in Syracuse, talks with MuggleCast

first! I go to SU but Im studying in London :-( not that its a bad thing but Im bummed I missed the only HP event at SU boo

Nice! Gonna listen to MuggleCast soon :D

What a fantastic opportunity! I am such a dork when it comes to the first four movie soundtracks. I listen to the John Williams scores ALL the time and I really like what Patrick Doyle did for the fourth movie. Wish I could say the same for Order of the Phoenix. I cringe to think that we will have THREE more movies filled with drivel from Nicholas Hooper.

the 3rd soundtrack is so genius

Are you JOKING HDMSTRSNAPE??? Patrick Doyles music was DEAD DEPRESSING! Especially at the end credits... It felt like i attended a funeral march.. there wasnt an ounce of happiness in his music... and I hated it... Hooper on the other hand KNEW how to balance the dark with the light and made a great music! HBP was his last movie though.. John Williams will finish the rest

phoenixknighter, everyone has opinions, and they dont necessarily have to the same as yours ok? I personally thought Hoopers score for OoTP was complete rubbish. The soundtrack felt completely flat and lifeless. The themes he composed were unmemorable and all over the place. The score itself had no central or underlying theme or motif to make it stand out amongst the scores by Williams or even Doyle.

I couldnt agree more ronbon. That music feels like a culmination, a refining of the the themes begun in the first two scores. I listen to it a ridiculous amount. phoenixknighter, I know you love the confrontation but there was a bit of death wound thru the fourth story if you hadnt noticed. I am intrigued about your comment concerning the remaining films. Can you quote your source? Thanks for the feedback.

Thats why I loved Hooper so much, he didnt have to have a recurring annoying theme like Doyle and his "Harry in the Winter" theme, lol. Hooper had two MAIN themes, that developed and grew as the story progressed.. like Umbridges theme and the Possession theme. If you pay close attention in the movie especially, those two themes grow until they become their own song.. the ONLY theme that should be played the most througout is Hedwigs theme, nothing else.. and with Doyle it sounded like he was changing the theme or something which I didnt like. Anyway thats my opinion but i know ALOT of people agree with me, cuz a lot of them didnt like GOF... I loved the movie, didnt so much like the music. OOTP, Loved the movie and music

YEah HDMSTRSNAPE, It was on mugglenet a couple months ago.. which is a good thing! If theres ONE thing i liked about the first 2 HP movies.. its the COMPOSER! Williams will be finishing DH, and its good, so long as it doesnt sound too much like his other works (Star Wars, Hook, Indiana Jones etc.) lol jk. Anyway thats cool. As much As i loved Hooper, hes not the one to finish the series.. One thing a movie franchise will always be remembered for is its music.

suhWEET

UGH! I go to SU! I couldve BEEN there! Except Im studying abroad in Italy...I think Italy might over rull that, but I am still sad I missed it! And I need to know this person who is studying abroad in London, I need to be friends with person, if Im not already.

Hey, I live in Syracuse, and didnt know about this! Wouldve been interesting to go.