Deathly Hallows won't be the largest film of 2010?
According to Times Online, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 1 won't be the biggest film of 2010. They believe Iron Man 2 will be the biggest. Here's the reasoning for why Deathly Hallows won't take the top spot:Part one of the final Harry Potter movie. Part two will follow in July 2011. Devoted fans have known what happens in the story since 2007; for newcomers, Harry and his pals Ron and Hermione search for some magical artefacts called Horcruxes. The plot takes the trainee wizards out of Hogwarts for much of the movie, resulting in a marked change of atmosphere compared to its predecessors.
Do you agree with Times Online? We sure don't! The Harry Potter franchise is the greatest earning franchise of all time, and a second Iron Man certainly won't earn more than a Potter flick.
Posted by Andrew on Oct 30th |
128 Comments


Visitor Comments















I could see that, especially since the books are all out. But I still think it will e among the top : )
=\ oh well...i'm just happy the series is being finished *nods*
Oh please, Iron Man doesn't come close to Harry Potter. HP FOREVER!!!
total crap - i don't believe that for a second
HP is the best--nothing can change that
I honestly can't see that happening. Even putting my radical fandom aside, I just don't think that could be the case at all. The franchise will have been going on longer than a decade; Iron Man can not beat that even if it tried, it's just logic.
yeah--Harry Potter may not be the top movie of the year--but it's going to be close. There are some things that are just great and memorable in this world. These last two movies are going to be the best! And it's safe to say, that if it doesn't beat Iron Man 2 in the box office, Harry Potter will for surely give Iron Man a run for its money! :D
I'm completely torn between the possibility of this. I'm a fan of both. ...EFF I'M GOING TO REMAIN IMPARTIAL NO ONE CAN STOP ME HAHA
I don't believe that. The HP audience is MUCH MUCH MUCH wider in age range and gender compared to Iron Man. I also think they're underestimating the fan base for HP. If their reasoning is that we know what is going to happen then I can counter that with that we have known what's going to happen in all the films so far but does that stop us? I don't think so...
I think HP will surpass Iron Man. The fan base is huge and we have been waiting for the beginning of the end forever now. Pre-sale tickets alone might be what put the sales over the edge. I can't wait.... 2010 can't come soon enough!
Heck no an iron man flick is NOT going to beat out ANY harry potter movie and certainly it won't beat out DEATHLY HALLOWS!!! Geeze, are they being serious now? Harry Potter all the way! Kick butt at box office!!! EPIC, it will be epic, I say!! LOL!
its a sequel, i really doubt it will be as good as the first one. And this movie is the end, i think both part 1 and two are going to make more than SS. And HP the movies have been around alot longer than Iron Man, but that doesn't mean Iron Man won't be successful because it probably will be, just not as much as HP :)
People WAKE UP! It's 'The Harry Potter' we are talking about. There's not a chance that a movie like IM-2 will stop it from ruling the box office. I personally think DH will be the biggest hit HP movie.
Sure. The biggest movie franchise of all time is coming out with the first part of the final movie and it will be beaten by... Iron Man 2. Makes total sense. ???
i'll see both, but harry potter is certainly going to be better, i'll watch it like 3 times in the theater and many times on dvd! DH will be amazing
While i love Iron man From all my heart , I can't see it making 900 million $ like HP , Also Hp 6 has made 932 million Untill now , That's a guaranteed 900 million $ for part 1 and 2 . Everybody who started watching Potter From the start , will watch teh seven one. Now Spiderman 4 may be another Story......
im not entirely sure id use the "The plot takes the trainee wizards out of Hogwarts for much of the movie, resulting in a marked change of atmosphere compared to its predecessors. " as a reason it wont do well... after 6 movies, its time for a change of scenery... and i bet people will embrace the new atmosphere...
Maybe... just because of some stupid decisions of the film makers, like what they did in the previous Two HP films.
Way to go and ruin the plot for people who only watch the film.
ahhh i dnt think so. are they implying that iron man has a bigger fan base or something because no matter that all the books are out and everyone knows what happens it wont stop anyone going to see the movies. Their excuses is stupid. and a new scenery is what the series needs after 6 books.
ahhh i dnt think so. are they implying that iron man has a bigger fan base or something because no matter that all the books are out and everyone knows what happens it wont stop anyone going to see the movies. Their excuses is stupid. and a new scenery is what the series needs after 6 books.
ahhh i dnt think so. are they implying that iron man has a bigger fan base or something because no matter that all the books are out and everyone knows what happens it wont stop anyone going to see the movies. Their excuses is stupid. and a new scenery is what the series needs after 6 books.
PFFFT! Iron man beat harry potter?!!! WTF!!!!!! Si nce this is finale of the harry potter films (well, the first part of it), shouldn't that make people more eager to watch it, rather than not?! I seriously doubt Iron man will beat harry potter. Nearly half the population are harry potter fans! The times can go eff themselves...
no way on earth can iron man 2 beat HP!! thats just crazy. we have the years of waiting, the huge fanbase, the success of past films... go potter!! :D theres simply no comparison!!
Let the competition begin. Go HPDH! Trailer Addict, HBP B Rolls...4 of them, really good. Check 'em out. Saw it on RupertGrint.net
ooops, RupertGrint.US Sorry
Erm....Iron Man 1 wasn't that great, I mean it was good and it had Robert Downey Jr in but it wasn't anything special. But then again they spend most of their time in the last book, and I quote from a Very Potter Musical, wandering around "The mundane British countryside..." so if that's what people think then I expect the first part of the Deathly Hallows has the potential to not do as well as other films (I highly doubt it though).
All im gonna say is I saw Iron man opening day by mistake. Wasnt that hard to get a good seat. Harry Potter on the other hand, I had to book tickets months before and wait over and hour to go inside the theatre
Iron man, really? That doesn't seem so likely. Even if Iron Man made $98,618,668 in it's opening weekend and HBP $77,835,727 (according to boxofficemojo) doesn't mean Iron Man 2 is going to be more succesful.. (it has probably more to do with that HBP was released in the middle of the week).
Wow, you people are obsessed with money... The only ones who should care about what a movie is grossing are the producers and the studio. For the rest of us (and I'm assuming here that the previous posters are in fact not film industry execs) the only thing that should matter is, well, let's call it quality, shall we? You like the movie, great. If not, fine. But what in the world do you care how much money it made?
dis is total rubbish...as many of us hv alreaddy said...v hv alwez known d stories of evry movee b4 it ws released thru d buks..so i don't think datknowing d story 4m d past 3 yrs will make a difference...v hv in w8ing 4 it 4 sooo long....dis is utter rubbish...n v r all really luking fwd 2 a change of scenery...getting outta hogwarts z nt bad @ all nor will it spoil ne fun!!!whoever said dis shud think nt twice bt a thousand tymss!!
I agree with muggleNet?!
Okay...so because Harry Potter is the biggest franchise EVER and it's on its LAST book in the first HALF of the movie, it still won't compare to Iron Man 2, which is going to suck anyway because producers want money? Mhm. Okay. No way. HARRY POTTER
I'm a hardcore HP fan but I honestly believe there are more Marvel Fans then Harry Potter fans.
I don't agree, I think HP fans who have read the books are going to want to see if they screwed up the movie and HP fans who are just movie fans are going to see what happends next. I don't see how the DH book being out has anything to do with people no wanting to watch the movie.
How funny, Iron Man 2 actually thinks they can take the top spot. We all know the Harry Potter movies have been on the top even before they thought of makin the Iron Man movies. The money this movie is going to bring will far exceed Iron Man 2. Good try Times, good try.
While Harry Potter may be the highest-grossing franchise, the reason is only because it has 6 films. Iron Man surpassed all of the Harry Potter films but the first in terms of domestic grossage, and while Harry Potter is an international favourite, Iron Man will definitely be the largest in terms of domestic grossage. I don't agree with the Times' reasoning, but they are right, depending on how you look at it.
HAHAHA! Yeah ok. Harry Potter will dominate.
awww hell no! nothing can beat harry potter, least of all iron man 2 :)
Bunch of bollocks. Enough said. I don't believe this for an instant.
No, yes they are out of Hogwarts but that makes the book even more interesting than the others right? It's something diferent this time. Money money money
Iron man WAS a good movie, but A. Usually Sequels (not series) suck and B. It's going up agains a Harry Potter film. C. It's the last book. What are they thinking? They must have someone from a different planet writing this stuff.
We are a huge HP fan family. Big time, for a decade. And, we loved Iron Man. Really - what a great film! Recommended it to lots of folks. BUT - we didn't go back and see it - three times! Never considered buying the soundtrack, or standing in line for hours to buy tickets so we could stand in line for hours to get good seats. A lot. Won't pre-order or even purchase the DVD, but will likely Red-Box it. Marvel fans are awesome, and I hope they get as good a sequel as the original. I just don't get the comparison. It's like when people compare Twilight to HP. Two completely different machines.
Who knows what'll happen? But I'm definitely on Team Potter. In my opinion, this movie will be THE biggest next year, no doubt about it. I mean it's the LAST book - all of the fans will want to see it. But again, you never know :)
What? That's like the lamest reason ever! Iron Man 2 will do well but not as well as DH pt1 or pt 2! Just look at HBP: everyone pretty much knew "snape kills Dumbledore" but it broke tons of records and made loads of money!!! Times should not say that just because everyone knows what happens doesn't mean people wont go watch the movie!
Oh pur-lease! Harry Potter Rox! Iron Man, SchmIron Man! That can NEVER beat Harry Potter! HP rocks dudes... I mean IRON MAN?????!!!!!! If this movie DOES beat (and I'm not saying it will) Harry Potter, I'll SCREAM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :)
I could see why that could be true. The first day that Iron Man came out, it did so good, that they decided that same day to make a second one. Even if Iron Man does do better then Part 1, well who cares. 1st, 2nd, or 46th, I'm still a die hard HP fa and it doesn't matter to me what spot HP falls into.
The first Iron Man doesn't even come close to the Potter films. This one might get more hype, but this is also Part 1 on the last HP book. People want to see how the series ends, so that might give Harry more money.
ive never seen iron man but i do know that hp is epic!!!!even if it isnt,that doesnt matter.as long as the fans love it it doesnt matter how much $ it makes.
Who are they trying to kid? NEVER and I mean NEEEEVVVVVEEEERRRR underestimate the power of the fandom. I saw HBP 6 times in Theatres and I will def see DH at least 7. Iron Man doesn't come close!!!!
Back to Top