Our newest addition to the Essay Section titled "S.P.E.W: Did Hermione Get it Wrong?" comes to us from Isla and she ponders a very interesting question: Is it possible that house-elves, at large, do not want to be free, and that Hermione Granger was doing some kind of social damage by trying to make them so?

In the Op-Ed, Isla points to the fact that the house-elves were actually insulted when Hermione tried to free them in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire by hiding bits of clothing all over the Gryffindor common room. She also notes that Dobby, who, after being set free from the Malfoys, returned to Hogwarts to do chores once again, as if it was in his very nature to do domestic work.

But what do you think? House-elves might be ranked the lowest amongst magical creatures, truly the most disenfranchised...but what do we do about house-elves who are content with their position in magical society?

Comments

Posted by Noah Fried
10-28-2011at 4:40 PM

Fan Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus
 
Which MuggleNet specialty site is your favorite?

 

MNI
MNFF
CoS Forums
MuggleSpace

 

July 19, 2005 - Emerson and Melissa from Leaky interview author J.K. Rowling.
 
 

Question : Who was the student from Middlebury College that first adapted the sport of muggle quidditch for the IQA?
 
Alex Benepe
Alexander Manshel
Alicia Radford
 

No, I was merely reading the Muggle magazines. I do love knitting patterns."

Albus Dumbledore
Half-Blood Prince
When Arthur Weasley takes Harry and his pals to the Ministry of Magic they must first dial a secret code into a telephone keypad. He enters the number 62442. The letters underneath those numbers on a standard mobile phone spell out the word "magic".
 
 
Int'l Harry Potter Day - 15th Anniversary of Battle of Hogwarts
May 2nd, 2013


Victoire Weasley B-day
May 2nd, 2013


MISTI-Con Convention
May 9-13, 2013


Pomona Sprout B-day
May 15th, 2013


Username :
Password :
 Sign Up
 Forgot Password ?
 
 
V-Day2013 Option II   VDay2013   holidays2012   MuggleNet OWL Exams  
April Fool's Day 2012   GilderoyVDay   Happy Holidays 2011   Pottermore: Slytherin  
Pottermore: Hufflepuff   Pottermore: Ravenclaw   Pottermore: Gryffindor   Quidditch World Cup  
Halloween 2011   DHnagini   DHelderwand   DH2cast  
DH1Trio   DH Voldemort   DH_Trio   Deathly Hallows - Hermione  
Burning Hogwarts   Wizarding World   Draco   Half-Blood Prince Trio  
Harry   Hermione   LEGO Harry Potter  
 
 
  Twitter   Facebook   RSS   Tumblr