It's a question that has never been directly answered by J.K. Rowling, and one that we could talk about for days but never necessarily solve.

That said, we would like to have a discussion on this question anyway because it came up on the newest episode of Alohomora! - which has yet to be released - and it's often fun to ponder these wild questions.

We know from the canon that a Dementor's Kiss is the ultimate form of punishment, in which a Dementor clamps its jaws on a victim's mouth, leaving him or her in a vegetative state by sucking out the victim's soul.

But our question today is this - what exactly happens to this soul when it's sucked out? Is it instantly destroyed? Is the victim's soul doomed to a kind of Dementor purgatory where it continues to exist? Does the Dementor absorb that soul and with it the personality of the victim...therefore in some way becoming the victim?

That latter possibility is a bit crazy, but what do you think? Some answers to this question will be read on the next episode of Alohomora!

Comments

Posted by Noah Fried
03-21-2013at 6:50 PM

Fan Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus
 
Which MuggleNet specialty site is your favorite?

 

MNI
MNFF
CoS Forums
MuggleSpace

 

December 21, 2004 - Just hours after the first pre-orders were taken, Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince is already topping charts.
 
 

Question : What charm does Ron say he can use while driving a car instead of using the vehicle's mirrors?
 
Supersensory Charm
Substanstive Charm
Revealing Charm
 

What sort of person cries while someone's kissing them?

Ron Weasley
Order of the Phoenix, Chapter 21, Page 459
Harry's middle name is James, Hermione's is Jean, Ginny's is Molly - after her mother - and poor old Ron's is Bilius.
 
 
Int'l Harry Potter Day - 15th Anniversary of Battle of Hogwarts
May 2nd, 2013


Victoire Weasley B-day
May 2nd, 2013


MISTI-Con Convention
May 9-13, 2013


Pomona Sprout B-day
May 15th, 2013


Username :
Password :
 Sign Up
 Forgot Password ?
 
 
V-Day2013 Option II   VDay2013   holidays2012   MuggleNet OWL Exams  
April Fool's Day 2012   GilderoyVDay   Happy Holidays 2011   Pottermore: Slytherin  
Pottermore: Hufflepuff   Pottermore: Ravenclaw   Pottermore: Gryffindor   Quidditch World Cup  
Halloween 2011   DHnagini   DHelderwand   DH2cast  
DH1Trio   DH Voldemort   DH_Trio   Deathly Hallows - Hermione  
Burning Hogwarts   Wizarding World   Draco   Half-Blood Prince Trio  
Harry   Hermione   LEGO Harry Potter  
 
 
  Twitter   Facebook   RSS   Tumblr