All right, you didn't believe me when, in my review of The Princess Bride, I said there was no such thing as S. Morgenstern. But even though this book dispenses with Goldman's conceit of merely editing an abridged, "good parts" version of a Morgenstern original - indeed, it claims to be Morgenstern's work from start to finish - it still has William Goldman's name on the spine, the front cover, and the copyright page. The nature of this "collaboration" is even more transparent than those involving Lemony Snicket and N. E. Bode; and yet I am sure to receive several emails denouncing my ignorance because, surely, S. Morgenstern really lives!

Morgenstern himself (if you will) makes a delightful argument for his own existence in a letter to the publisher, printed at the beginning of this book.

You say in several places [in the 'good parts' version of The Princess Bride] that I am dead. As I sit here and watch my fingers form this note, I am forced to believe that you are in error. I am old, but alive. Perhaps as you age, you will find the two are not mutually exclusive.

Nevertheless, I congratulate Mr. Goldman on the revival of his charming alter ego, who in a few brisk chapters (gorgeously illustrated by Paul Giovanopoulos) spins a tale of romance, humor, irony, magic, and destiny - all along the most beautiful street in the world, the Grand Canal in Venice.

Our hero is Luigi, an aspiring gondolier with an incredible gift for seamanship, but a tragic lack of singing ability. His story of heartbreak, heroism, and hope is, on the face of it, merely Morgenstern's explanation of why the Venetian gondoliers - long famed as the beautiful singers of the world - now punt along silently or, at most, to the accompaniment of hired accordion-players. And why, almost beyond belief, the silencing of so many glorious voices is actually not a tragedy at all.

Luigi lives in a world in which elements of fantasy, romance and magic mix with earthy characters and concrete reality. A world in which even a happy ending may be bittersweet because not every hope is fulfilled in the way one originally expected; a world in which suffering, danger, and humiliation are landmarks on the hero's journey, in which the ridiculous marches shoulder-to-shoulder with the poignant, and in which deaf opera coaches, projectile vegetables, PG-13 language (hesitantly translated from Italian to English), and beer served by a guy named Porky VIII can form part of a timeless, heartwarming fable.

If you enjoyed reading The Princess Bride, you will definitely enjoy this leaner, tighter, less discursive cousin - even though it is set in something more like the real world. Goldman's writing has a wonderful directness, a kind of street-wise poetry so that, even when he inevitably digresses from his point, he does so in prose that reads effortlessly, tickling that nameless part inside you that only laughs out of pure joy.

Robbie Fischer
USA

Recommended Age: 13+

If you would like to contact Robbie, you may do so here.

---

MuggleNet is an unofficial Harry Potter fan site. Please email us if you have any questions or concerns. MuggleNet's original layouts were designed and created by Navy. All subsequent layouts by Dylan Spartz.

© 1999-2009 MuggleNet.com. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy | COPPA Policy | Feedback | Credits
Random Addresses

836 muggles currently online