Stanley's version of the family luck hits him in the form of a pair of sneakers, which fall off a freeway overpass and hit him on the head. The next thing he knows, he's arrested for stealing a pro baseball star's sneakers which were supposed to be auctioned off for charity, and no one believes in his innocence, so he is convicted and sentenced to 18 months (!!!) in a boys' correctional facility called Camp Green Lake.

It's some camp: the counselors carry guns.

It's some Green Lake: located in the middle of a huge Texas desert, in a dry lakebed in which each boy is required to dig a hole five feet deep and five feet around every day.

Poor flabby Stanley, surrounded by juvenile criminals in a somewhat savage pecking order, and overseen by guards ranging from the hypocritical Mr. Pendansky to the ruthless Mr. Sir (who is always saying something to the effect of "This isn't a Girls Scout camp") to the truly monstrous female warden, who is frightening from the very first moment you see her. Stanley Yelnats doesn't stand a chance.

Worse than the scorpions or the rattlesnakes, are the yellow-spotted lizards whose bite is instantly fatal. It hasn't rained there for 100 years, the heat of the sun is brutal, the work is back-breaking, and it seems the reason they're digging holes has less to do with building character and more to do with looking for something. Then, the only real friend Stanley has decides he can't take it anymore and goes walking off into the desert alone.

The book incorporates three of four different interlacing storylines, from different points in history, and brings them together in a richly satisfying way that smacks of "destiny" and "redemption" and "poetic justice." It also shows a soft kid toughening up, then (just as he's starting to really harden), softening again...or rather, becoming a better person, a true friend, and an unexpected hero.

Holes has lots of stuff to delight readers of all ages. It has a sinister conspiracy. It has a youthful friendship in an environment like the polar opposite of Hogwarts (the kid goes from a happy family to the most horrible possible learning environment and social structure). It has suspense, adventure, romance, surprise, coincidences guaranteed to make you either laugh aloud or get choked up, tragedy, and dark comedy. It has a family folk tale embedded in it (about a boy who takes a gypsy woman's advice on how to win the hand of a beautiful girl), it has a bit of western melodrama (about a man who, robbed of his entire fortune by a famous female outlaw, wanders out of the desert weeks later delirious and muttering something about "taking refuge under God's thumb"), it has a beautiful romance turned into a sad mystery by the racial politics of the 19th-century South, it has buried treasure, it has survival drama in the wilderness, it has a hint of the ghost story in it, and it has a woman who tortures her victims by scratching them with fingernails freshly painted in rattlesnake venom. The first time she says, "Excuse me," I felt a chill go down my spine.

YOU MUST READ THIS BOOK. If you're like me you've seen it at stores and may have even been tempted to read it before, but now you know on good authority (mine) that it's good. So get it! Love it! And share it!

And by the way, the recent movie based on this book meets my full approval, though I would advise reading the book whether you see the movie or not.

Robbie Fischer
Arizona USA

Recommended Age: 10+

If you would like to contact Robbie, you may do so here.

---

MuggleNet is an unofficial Harry Potter fan site. Please email us if you have any questions or concerns. MuggleNet's original layouts were designed and created by Navy. All subsequent layouts by Dylan Spartz.

© 1999-2008 MuggleNet.com. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy | COPPA Policy | Feedback | Credits
Random Addresses

1,750 muggles currently online