The GoF and OotP Movies
An original editorial by Sahar Bala
After the recent release of the excellent movie, The Prisoner of Azkaban, most Harry Potter fans are eagerly awaiting the fourth and fifth movies, The Goblet of Fire, and The Order of the Phoenix. As for me, I am anticipating the movies just excitedly as everyone else, but I also am hoping for a little variation, perhaps a rating change.
After watching the third movie, I was pleasantly surprised. The director, Cuaron, had not taken the kid-movie road I had expected him to follow, as Columbus had done. He put suspense and drama into the movie, it was remotely more frightening than the first two movies. It also seemed more epical than the SS/PS and CoS movies, which were more adventure movies.
The first three movies had been filmed to meet a PG rating. I am crossing my fingers, hoping that the fourth and fifth movies will be filmed to meet a PG-13 rating. Not that I dont enjoy having younger kids in the movie theater, I just dont think that the books will be accurately portrayed if the movies arent allowed to be a little scary.
For example, The Goblet of Fire has some very horrific scenes in it, the graveyard scene being, of course, the most prominent. Firstly, the whole rebirthing of Voldemort takes place in a graveyard. The whole point of having this scene take place in a graveyard, (besides Voldemort needing his fathers bones) is to set a horribly scary mood. Next, nearly the first thing that happens when Harry and Cedric take the Portkey is Cedrics murder. Cedrics death adds to the grief and suspense of the scene. How are you supposed to make a dark graveyard and the death of a fellow student less scary? The thing is, they are supposed to be scary.
The cutting of Wormtails hand, Cedrics death, the torturing of Harry, and Voldemorts and Harrys duel are parts that I am expecting to be extremely terrifying. I will be sorely disappointed if either: certain parts are cut (Wormtails hand) or if the entire scene is made less scary to invite a younger audience. I especially like the part where Voldemort rises from the cauldron, a dark silhouette through the potions mist; and also the Death Eaters apparating to the site.
The whole plot of The Order of the Phoenix is based on suspense and darkness. We know that Voldemort is back and that the Ministry is doing nothing to stop him. That has to be a little scary and suspenseful, hasnt it? The MoM scene isnt for children either; it is a major battle. And we cannot forget the death of Sirius. As I was reading the book, at the part where Voldemort appears in the hall, I was nearly trembling with the suspense. I only hope that the movie will make the audience do the same.
I also hope that the anger and sadness shown in the book isnt subdued in the movie. In OotP, Harry shows more anger than he does in any of the other books. Anger at his friends, teachers, Cho, and Dumbledore. I think the anger adds to the suspense and darkness of the book. I really loved the sadness shown in the books. Suddenly, after five books, you finally really feel Harrys pain of losing his parents and the closest thing to a parent he had ever had. I admit that I sobbed when Harry was sitting by the lake, thinking of Sirius, and I hope the movie makes the audience understand the pain that Harry is going through. I am placing my trust in Daniel Radcliffes acting skills, hoping that he will progress as he has been doing, getting better acting Harry with each movie.
I think it is an insult to J.K. Rowling not to show the suspense that she wrote her books to show. The suspense and gloominess of her books are part of her theme, and I think that changing that just so a few kids wont have nightmares isnt worth it. Let us hope the directors feel the same way.