About Books Movies Discussion Support Support Support
 
MuggleNet Potter Profiles | Fan of the Week

Potter Profile - Melanie

August 23, 2009



First off, how did you become a Harry Potter fan?
It's kind of a long story... I wanted to see the third film for my birthday, but I had not read any of the books beforehand. However my mom had, and I wanted to know what was going to happen in that movie. But when I asked her, she could not remember so I went to the library to check it so it would jog her memory and she could tell me...however, I started reading it...and I couldn't put it down, it was amazing.

How are you feeling now that the series is over?
It is extremely depressing, I have just recently finished HP7 for the second time...but I see re-reading the whole series over again in the future, to make myself feel better. It had to end eventually of course, but it is still very sad.

So, Half-Blood Prince is out in theaters. What did you think?
I saw it at midnight, and to be honest, I thought it was the best film yet, but it wasn't Harry Potter. It was the most well done as a feature by itself, but compared to the other films it just didn't go. And for every serious or dramatic scene there were 3 humorous for it. Then again, the scene in the lake was perfection, and the scene where they all lift their wands is extremely touching. Overall, a good movie.

What part of the book was left in that you were SO EXCITED to see come to life?
I really wanted to see Harry as Captain. And although it was cut short, it was still a scene that was very funny, I just liked seeing Harry in control like that, like the DA, it was well done. Although it is sort of depressing, that there won't be anymore Quidditch...but oh well.

What did the film makers leave out that left you a little disappointed?
Although there were a lot of memories, I feel that they should have included the memory in which they visit the Gaunts. I thought that was very important is seeing where Voldemort really came from. The orphanage was his childhood, but that is not where he got his traits from. I felt like that scene was needed in order to really show the darkness, and gruesome past that led Voldemort to who he was. And also, to actually show the Horcruxs, and how proud Marvolo was of them, because that certainly showed through with Voldemort.

How did you feel about the Half-Blood Prince portion of the storyline? Were you satisfied?
I guess that part was alright, however when Snape finally said that he was the Half-Blood Prince it wasn't an unbelieveable moment. Because they did not go that much into it. Harry did bring it up a couple of times, and normally when it did come up, it was in a humurous fashion, so when the outcome came it wasn't as serious as it was in the book. The only serious scene was when Harry used Sectumsempa, out of all the other scenes with the book.

After leaving the theater, how did you feel? Did the movie leave you excited, sad, or something else?
Leaving the theater, I was very excited. However it kind of ruined it because I went with a couple of people who came out making fun of it, so, with them chatting about, it didn't help my excitement for it. However, it eased my pain when I saw it the next day with my dad. Who thought it was amazing as well. and we talked positively about it, and then I was all excited again! The only thing that I was sad about is that it was the sixth, theres only going to be two more, that its almost over.

Is there anything else you would like to add?
I originally saw the post on Mugglenet for Harry Potter the Musical, now known as A Very Potter Musical, and I watched it that day. And I just have to say that it is the most hystarical thing that I have ever seen. It puts all the books together, and the songs are fantastic, everyone can act and sing. And I strongly urge everyone to watch it if they haven't seen it yet!!


Back to Potter Profiles


 
Most Commented
Big
News
Top Commentors
Loading...
Which stars next film are you looking most forward to?

 

Woman in Black - Dan
Perks of Being a Wallfower - Emma
Into the White

 

July 25, 2006 - The paperback edition of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince is released in the United States.
 
 

Please login to participate in MuggleNet's Daily Trivia Competition!

Yeah? Did he [Mark Evans] say you look like a pig that's been taught to walk on its hind legs? 'Cause that's not cheek, Dud, that's true...

Harry Potter
Order of the Phoenix, Chapter 1, Page 13
J.K. Rowling's books were the first children's books included on the New York Bestseller list since E.B. White's Charlotte's Web in 1952.
 
 

BAFTA & Grammy Awards
February 12

MegaCon with Tom Felton
February 17-19

Academy Awards
February 26

Studio Tour
March 31, 2012

Username :
Password :
 Sign Up
 Forgot Password ?
 
 
 
Happy Holidays 2011   Pottermore: Slytherin   Pottermore: Hufflepuff   Pottermore: Ravenclaw  
Pottermore: Gryffindor   Quidditch World Cup   Halloween 2011   DHnagini  
DHelderwand   DH2cast   DH1Trio   DH Voldemort  
DH_Trio   Deathly Hallows - Hermione   Burning Hogwarts   Wizarding World  
Draco   Half-Blood Prince Trio   Harry   Hermione  
LEGO Harry Potter  
 
 
Change Background
 
  Twitter   Facebook   RSS   Tumblr