Quibble of the Week: “Gryffindor House: The Convenient Generic?”

Our next Quibble of the Week comes from Abbii, and is a rather critical piece re-evaluating the overall significance of what is, perhaps, one of the fandom’s most celebrated houses.

She poses, for example, that Hermione might have been a much better fit for Ravenclaw given her great intellect, and that she – quite like a notable forgetful character in the series – was put in Gryffindor not solely for her real attributes, but because she would play such a crucial role in the story’s plot.

Many of you are Gryffindor – but don’t judge this quibble too harshly, because it’s a valid critique of the text after all, and raises an important question: Did J.K. Rowling simply create Gryffindor House to better sustain her story centered around the heroic boy wizard?

To read more quibbles, just visit our essay section.

Welcome to MuggleNet!


Would you like to join our mailing list?