Skip to content

MuggleNet

  • Site
    • Contact Us & FAQ
    • History
    • Meet the Team
    • MuggleNet Live!
    • Press
    • Publications
    • Special Projects
    • Volunteer with Us!
    • Year in Review
  • Podcasts
    • Alohomora!
    • Full Circle
    • LITHAPPENS
    • Potterversity
    • Promptly Potter
    • SpeakBeasty
  • Harry Potter
    • Book Quotes
    • Book Series
    • Coloring Books
    • Film Companions
    • Film Series
    • Hogwarts Library
    • Little Things
    • Music
    • Video Games
  • Fantastic Beasts
    • Book
    • Coloring Books
    • Film Companions
    • Fantastic Beasts Film Quotes
    • Film Series
    • Little Things
    • Music
    • Video Games
  • The Quibbler
    • Owl Post
    • Bathilda’s Notebook
    • The Department of MYTHteries
    • The Dirigible Plum
    • Into the Floo
    • Muggle Studies
    • The Pensieve Papers
    • The Three Broomsticks
    • April Fools’
    • The Quibbler Vault
  • The Daily Prophet
    • Book Trolley
    • Editorials
    • Event Reports
    • Exclusive Interviews
    • Features
    • Giveaways
    • Listicles
    • Merchandise Reviews
    • Movie Reviews
    • Television Reviews
    • Theater Reviews
    • Wizolympics
  • Muggle World
    • Charity
    • Exhibitions
    • J.K. Rowling
    • MinaLima
    • Quadball
    • Studio Tours
    • Theatrical Play
    • Theme Parks
    • Wizarding World Digital
  • Fans & Fun
    • Crazy Caption Contest
    • Fan Focus
    • Fandom
    • Fandom Sortings
    • Fandom Timeline
    • Fun Lists
    • Games and Trivia
    • GNOMEs
    • Potter DIY
    • Potter Weddings
    • #PotterItForward
    • Rosmerta’s Recipes
    • Song Parodies
    • Wizard Rock
    • Wizarding Wordle
  • Site
    • Contact Us & FAQ
    • History
    • Meet the Team
    • MuggleNet Live!
    • Press
    • Publications
    • Special Projects
    • Volunteer with Us!
    • Year in Review
  • Podcasts
    • Alohomora!
    • Full Circle
    • LITHAPPENS
    • Potterversity
    • Promptly Potter
    • SpeakBeasty
  • Harry Potter
    • Book Quotes
    • Book Series
    • Coloring Books
    • Film Companions
    • Film Series
    • Hogwarts Library
    • Little Things
    • Music
    • Video Games
  • Fantastic Beasts
    • Book
    • Coloring Books
    • Film Companions
    • Fantastic Beasts Film Quotes
    • Film Series
    • Little Things
    • Music
    • Video Games
  • The Quibbler
    • Owl Post
    • Bathilda’s Notebook
    • The Department of MYTHteries
    • The Dirigible Plum
    • Into the Floo
    • Muggle Studies
    • The Pensieve Papers
    • The Three Broomsticks
    • April Fools’
    • The Quibbler Vault
  • The Daily Prophet
    • Book Trolley
    • Editorials
    • Event Reports
    • Exclusive Interviews
    • Features
    • Giveaways
    • Listicles
    • Merchandise Reviews
    • Movie Reviews
    • Television Reviews
    • Theater Reviews
    • Wizolympics
  • Muggle World
    • Charity
    • Exhibitions
    • J.K. Rowling
    • MinaLima
    • Quadball
    • Studio Tours
    • Theatrical Play
    • Theme Parks
    • Wizarding World Digital
  • Fans & Fun
    • Crazy Caption Contest
    • Fan Focus
    • Fandom
    • Fandom Sortings
    • Fandom Timeline
    • Fun Lists
    • Games and Trivia
    • GNOMEs
    • Potter DIY
    • Potter Weddings
    • #PotterItForward
    • Rosmerta’s Recipes
    • Song Parodies
    • Wizard Rock
    • Wizarding Wordle
  • The Quibbler / The Wizard's Voice

In Jo’s Defense: Regarding Dumbledore’s Sexuality in “The Crimes of Grindelwald”

by Victor Chan · February 5, 2018

David Yates should probably stop giving interviews, for a while at least. It seems like every time he opens his mouth, he causes a PR nightmare. Having previously angered a lot of Harry Potter fans by claiming that the controversy surrounding Johnny Depp’s casting in Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald was “a dead issue,” the Fantastic Beasts director, according to Entertainment Weekly, has also stated that Dumbledore’s sexuality will not be “explicitly” addressed in the Fantastic Beasts sequel. Unsurprisingly, Yates’s comments were met with widespread condemnation on Twitter.

 

https://twitter.com/dreamoforgonon/status/958756026278432769

this franchise is so fucking smug about how ~inclusive~ and ~progressive~ it is while routinely shutting out anyone who isn't a cishet white person.

— Angie J. Han (@ajhan) January 31, 2018

Let’s all just agree that you don’t get brownie points for saying a character you wrote or filmed is gay if they’re not actually, you know, gay in any way.

— Joanna Robinson (@jowrotethis) January 31, 2018

https://twitter.com/scottEweinberg/status/958778068830752768

 

J.K. Rowling, doing little to dissipate the situation, appeared to dismiss fans’ concerns regarding the portrayal or lack thereof of Dumbledore’s sexuality in Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald.

 

Being sent abuse about an interview that didn't involve me, about a screenplay I wrote but which none of the angry people have read, which is part of a five-movie series that's only one instalment in, is obviously tons of fun, but you know what's even *more* fun? pic.twitter.com/Rj6Zr8aKUk

— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) January 31, 2018

 

Rowling’s revelation in 2007 that she had always pictured Dumbledore as a gay character was met with mixed reception. Some considered Rowling’s outing of Dumbledore as a progressive decision, while others criticized her for not making that aspect of the character directly apparent in the books. Still, others wondered whether she was trying to score points with the LGBTQ+ community.

At the time, Rowling joked, “Just imagine the fan fiction now.” Nine years on, the depiction of Albus Potter and Scorpius Malfoy’s relationship in Harry Potter and the Cursed Child was perceived to be guilty of queerbaiting. During this time, Rowling was also accused of culturally appropriating Native American folklore in “History of Magic in North America” on Pottermore. Many in the Harry Potter fandom had begun to express their discontent that Rowling’s wizarding world, a universe that promotes diversity and inclusivity, was not as progressive as it could be.

When Rowling announced that the Fantastic Beasts series would delve into the history between Dumbledore and Grindelwald, many fans were excited that the subtext surrounding Dumbledore’s sexuality would be brought to the surface. Addressing Dumbledore’s sexuality directly was seen as an opportunity for Rowling to practice what she had preached. The frustration of some Harry Potter fans is understandable – most of them have waited their entire lives to see themselves represented in this universe, and Rowling herself once tweeted that “If Harry Potter taught us anything, it’s that no one should live in a closet.”

 

.@claraoswiin But of course. pic.twitter.com/Galu47MT4X

— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) December 16, 2014

 

With that being said, however, I feel that some people are being premature with their reactions to Yates’s statement. Since we’ve yet to see a trailer for Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald, and know very little about its plot, it’s impossible for us to ascertain how prominent Dumbledore’s role will be in this installment of the franchise. Yates’s use of the word “explicitly” is quite ambiguous. Also, despite being the film’s director, he doesn’t come across as the most reliable person in the Entertainment Weekly article. In a throwaway line, he adds that Dumbledore and Grindelwald “ fell in love with each other’s ideas, and ideology and each other,” contradicting Rowling’s previous claim that Dumbledore’s feelings toward Grindelwald were unrequited.

Dumbledore’s sexuality not being explicitly addressed in Crimes of Grindelwald does not necessarily suggest that his sexuality will not be explored at all – their relationship could be visually alluded to. Nor does Yates’s statement suggest that his sexuality won’t be explicitly addressed in future installments of this film series. And as much as it may offend a lot of fans, I can understand why Rowling would want to treat Dumbledore’s sexuality subtlely, in Crimes of Grindelwald at least. Consider everything that we know about Dumbledore thus far. He’s an extremely private person who was so ashamed of his pure-blood supremacist past that he tried to make an amends for it by dedicating his entire life to promoting equality among Muggles, Muggle-borns, pure-bloods, and nonhuman beings. Dumbledore spent most of his life avoiding any confrontation with Grindelwald, and it seems that not even Rita Skeeter was able to uncover the extent of his feelings for Grindelwald. It would not be out of character for Dumbledore to conceal this aspect of his past from Newt. After all, he did the same with Harry.

Although Rowling hasn’t handled the controversy regarding Dumbledore’s sexuality as well as she could have, at this point, I’m still willing to give her the benefit of the doubt and hope that she’ll able to do justice to her beloved character.

 

The Wizard’s Voice provides a critical look at some of the more contentious topics within the Harry Potter universe, as well as their interconnectivity to the Muggle world where relevant.
Want more posts like this one? MuggleNet is 99% volunteer-run, and we need your help. With your monthly pledge of $1, you can interact with creators, suggest ideas for future posts, and enter exclusive swag giveaways!

Support us on Patreon

Social:

  • Next story Events Roundup: A Guide to a Magical 2018!
  • Previous story A Harry Potter-Themed Tour in New York City You Didn’t Know Existed

MuggleNet Archive

Important Dates

July 2025

Mon, Jul 7

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - Part 2 movie (London premiere)
Recurs yearly

2011

Tue, Jul 8

Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire book
Recurs yearly

2000

Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban book (UK)
Recurs yearly

1999

WWoHP Diagon Alley at Universal Orlando's anniversary
Recurs yearly

2014

Wed, Jul 9

David O'Hara's birthday
Recurs yearly

Albert Runcorn

Thu, Jul 10

Fiona Shaw's birthday
Recurs yearly

Petunia Dursley

Fri, Jul 11

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix movie (US)
Recurs yearly

2007

MuggleNet podcasts are sponsored in part by Secretlab.

Thanks to its research-backed ergonomic design, including a proprietary 4-way adaptive lumbar support system, the Secretlab TITAN Evo Harry Potter Edition will comfortably support you even when you’re up to no good.

Did You Know

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows was released on July 21, 2007, and sold 11 million copies on the first day of its release, becoming the fastest selling book of all time.

Potter History

November 27, 2005 – Tolga Safer, David Heyman, Miranda Richardson, Daniel Radcliffe, Jamie Waylett, Katie Leung, Tiana Benjamin, and Mike Newell are interviewed at the Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire NYC red carpet.

Potter Quote

“You are a braver man by far than Igor Karkaroff. You know, I sometimes think we sort too soon. . . .”

MuggleNet is an unofficial Harry Potter fansite.
Please email us if you have any questions or concerns.
© 1999–2025 MuggleNet.com. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy | COPPA Policy | Terms of Use | Feedback


MuggleNet is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and Bookshop.org's affiliate program, affiliate advertising programs designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com and bookshop.org.