Skip to content

MuggleNet

  • Site
    • Contact Us & FAQ
    • History
    • Meet the Team
    • MuggleNet Live!
    • Press
    • Publications
    • Special Projects
    • Volunteer with Us!
    • Year in Review
  • Podcasts
    • Alohomora!
    • Full Circle
    • LITHAPPENS
    • Potterversity
    • Promptly Potter
    • SpeakBeasty
  • Harry Potter
    • Book Quotes
    • Book Series
    • Coloring Books
    • Film Companions
    • Film Series
    • Hogwarts Library
    • Little Things
    • Music
    • Video Games
  • Fantastic Beasts
    • Book
    • Coloring Books
    • Film Companions
    • Fantastic Beasts Film Quotes
    • Film Series
    • Little Things
    • Music
    • Video Games
  • The Quibbler
    • Owl Post
    • Bathilda’s Notebook
    • The Department of MYTHteries
    • The Dirigible Plum
    • Into the Floo
    • Muggle Studies
    • The Pensieve Papers
    • The Three Broomsticks
    • April Fools’
    • The Quibbler Vault
  • The Daily Prophet
    • Book Trolley
    • Editorials
    • Event Reports
    • Exclusive Interviews
    • Features
    • Giveaways
    • Listicles
    • Merchandise Reviews
    • Movie Reviews
    • Television Reviews
    • Theater Reviews
    • Wizolympics
  • Muggle World
    • Charity
    • Exhibitions
    • J.K. Rowling
    • MinaLima
    • Quadball
    • Studio Tours
    • Theatrical Play
    • Theme Parks
    • Wizarding World Digital
  • Fans & Fun
    • Crazy Caption Contest
    • Fan Focus
    • Fandom
    • Fandom Sortings
    • Fandom Timeline
    • Fun Lists
    • Games and Trivia
    • GNOMEs
    • Potter DIY
    • Potter Weddings
    • #PotterItForward
    • Rosmerta’s Recipes
    • Song Parodies
    • Wizard Rock
    • Wizarding Wordle
  • Site
    • Contact Us & FAQ
    • History
    • Meet the Team
    • MuggleNet Live!
    • Press
    • Publications
    • Special Projects
    • Volunteer with Us!
    • Year in Review
  • Podcasts
    • Alohomora!
    • Full Circle
    • LITHAPPENS
    • Potterversity
    • Promptly Potter
    • SpeakBeasty
  • Harry Potter
    • Book Quotes
    • Book Series
    • Coloring Books
    • Film Companions
    • Film Series
    • Hogwarts Library
    • Little Things
    • Music
    • Video Games
  • Fantastic Beasts
    • Book
    • Coloring Books
    • Film Companions
    • Fantastic Beasts Film Quotes
    • Film Series
    • Little Things
    • Music
    • Video Games
  • The Quibbler
    • Owl Post
    • Bathilda’s Notebook
    • The Department of MYTHteries
    • The Dirigible Plum
    • Into the Floo
    • Muggle Studies
    • The Pensieve Papers
    • The Three Broomsticks
    • April Fools’
    • The Quibbler Vault
  • The Daily Prophet
    • Book Trolley
    • Editorials
    • Event Reports
    • Exclusive Interviews
    • Features
    • Giveaways
    • Listicles
    • Merchandise Reviews
    • Movie Reviews
    • Television Reviews
    • Theater Reviews
    • Wizolympics
  • Muggle World
    • Charity
    • Exhibitions
    • J.K. Rowling
    • MinaLima
    • Quadball
    • Studio Tours
    • Theatrical Play
    • Theme Parks
    • Wizarding World Digital
  • Fans & Fun
    • Crazy Caption Contest
    • Fan Focus
    • Fandom
    • Fandom Sortings
    • Fandom Timeline
    • Fun Lists
    • Games and Trivia
    • GNOMEs
    • Potter DIY
    • Potter Weddings
    • #PotterItForward
    • Rosmerta’s Recipes
    • Song Parodies
    • Wizard Rock
    • Wizarding Wordle
  • Features / The Daily Prophet

Why Fudge Refused Voldemort’s Return

by Lis Fricker · November 23, 2020

There are a lot of reasons to dislike Minister of Magic Cornelius Fudge and call him an ineffective leader. However, it may not be that Fudge denied Voldemort’s return in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix because he was an inadequate leader or a leader who denied the truth in order to stay in power. Trauma theory presents arguments that some of Fudge’s motivations to deny Voldemort’s return come from a very human place.

 

 

The first reason Fudge would not want to admit Voldemort had returned is that no one wants to be the bearer of bad news. Art historian and cultural theorist Kaja Silverman asserts in her book Male Subjectivity at the Margins that a traumatic event can interrupt society’s dominant fiction. The dominant fiction is the popular perception of a society’s way of life and goals at that moment. For example, the American Dream is a dominant fiction to have a nice car, a house with a white picket fence, and a backyard to host neighborhood barbeques. After Voldemort disappeared the night James and Lily died, wizarding society certainly seemed to have a similar idyllic dominant fiction to the American Dream. The fact Percy Weasley spent his time before the World Cup working on a report about cauldron bottom thickness regulations shows that the magical society seemed pretty calm. Why would Fudge want to obliterate the calm dominant fiction of a post-Voldemort world? As Lupin stated, “[A]ccepting that Voldemort’s back would mean trouble like the Ministry hasn’t had to cope with for nearly fourteen years” (OotP 94).

 

 

As Minister of Magic, Fudge had the power to shape the narrative to ensure the dominant fiction was not interrupted. Trauma scholar Kalí Tal notes in Worlds of Hurt: Reading the Literatures of Trauma, “Representation of traumatic experiences is ultimately a tool in the hands of those who shape public opinion and national myth” (19). Thus, the Minister relied on the press to turn Harry’s experiences at Voldemort’s resurrection into delusions of a disturbed teenage boy.

 

 

The techniques Fudge and the Daily Prophet used to maintain the dominant fiction are what scholar Kirby Farrell calls social adaptation and relearning. These processes involve the person who both directly and indirectly experienced the traumatic event to reframe or reprocess how the event happened within their own mind and memory. This is done to reduce guilt over what happened or to make it easier for the person to process the event to move on from it. Fudge used social adaption and relearning when he said Barty Crouch, Jr.’s statements before being given the Dementor’s Kiss could not be truthful because the man was a “raving lunatic.” Cedric Diggory’s death was a tragic accident during the Triwizard tournament, an event with a previous history of participant deaths. Harry wanted attention, found the names of those who had been tried as Death Eaters, and declared they had witnessed the Dark Lord’s return. Dumbledore was losing his marbles in his old age. The Azkaban breakout in Order of the Phoenix was done with the help of Sirius Black. As long as none of those aforementioned events were linked to Voldemort, the world could function as it had for nearly 15 years.

 

 

Maintaining the status quo meant Fudge could stay in power. Fudge knew there were smarter wizards who inspired more loyalty than himself (such as Dumbledore), and people would want someone else to lead magical Britain in the aftermath of Voldemort’s return. Granted, Fudge also had little incentive to want to disrupt the dominant narrative since all the indications are there that the people Harry accuses of being Death Eaters were lining the Minister’s pockets.

 

 

So in the end, Fudge’s refusal of Voldemort’s return lies in the fact that he was a bumbling man who liked to be in power. But trauma theory helps show that denying the Dark Lord’s return may have been more nuanced than simply a power move. Rather, it was a move that kept most people living in the idyllic dominant fiction where one of the most pressing issues for the international departments were cauldron bottom thickness.

 

Source

 

Want to learn more about trauma theory and representations of trauma in literature? Find Kirby Farrell’s Post-Traumatic Culture: Injury and Interpretation in the Nineties here:

Buy on Bookshop Buy on Amazon

 

Find Kaja Silverman’s Male Subjectivity at the Margins here:

Buy on Bookshop Buy on Amazon

 

Find Kalí Tal’s Worlds of Hurt: Reading the Literatures of Trauma here:

Buy on Bookshop Buy on Amazon

 

Want more posts like this one? MuggleNet is 99% volunteer-run, and we need your help. With your monthly pledge of $1, you can interact with creators, suggest ideas for future posts, and enter exclusive swag giveaways!

Support us on Patreon

Social:

  • Next story Become a Legendary Quidditch Coach with “Harry Potter”: Catch the Snitch Board Game by Knight Games!
  • Previous story Rupert Grint, Jude Law, and Gemma Chan Among Backers of “Choose Love” Campaign

MuggleNet Archive

Important Dates

June 2025

Tue, Jun 24

Cedric Diggory is murdered by Lord Voldemort, who got his body back
Recurs yearly

1995

Third task of Triwizard Tournament
Recurs yearly

1995

Thu, Jun 26

Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone book
Recurs yearly

1997

Ron tries to call Harry on the fellytone
Recurs yearly

1993

Tolga Safer's birthday
Recurs yearly

Igor Karkaroff’s aide

Fri, Jun 27

Matthew Lewis's birthday
Recurs yearly

Neville Longbottom

Sat, Jun 28

Dobby's birthday
Recurs yearly

Mon, Jun 30

Dumbledore and Harry go to cave for Horcrux
Recurs yearly

1997

Dumbledore is killed by Severus Snape
Recurs yearly

1997

Predrag Bjelac's birthday
Recurs yearly

Igor Karkaroff

MuggleNet podcasts are sponsored in part by Secretlab.

Thanks to its research-backed ergonomic design, including a proprietary 4-way adaptive lumbar support system, the Secretlab TITAN Evo Harry Potter Edition will comfortably support you even when you’re up to no good.

Did You Know

Shirley Henderson was aged 35 at the time that she first played Moaning Myrtle. She is the oldest actor to play a Hogwarts student in the Harry Potter films.

Potter History

July 18, 2007 – The New York Times posts an early review of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, which sets off fury among fans.

Potter Quote

“Of course it is happening inside your head, Harry, but why on earth should that mean it is not real?”

MuggleNet is an unofficial Harry Potter fansite.
Please email us if you have any questions or concerns.
© 1999–2025 MuggleNet.com. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy | COPPA Policy | Terms of Use | Feedback


MuggleNet is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and Bookshop.org's affiliate program, affiliate advertising programs designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com and bookshop.org.