Skip to content

MuggleNet

  • Site
    • Contact Us & FAQ
    • History
    • Meet the Team
    • MuggleNet Live!
    • Press
    • Publications
    • Special Projects
    • Volunteer with Us!
    • Year in Review
  • Podcasts
    • Alohomora!
    • Full Circle
    • LITHAPPENS
    • Potterversity
    • Promptly Potter
    • SpeakBeasty
  • Harry Potter
    • Book Quotes
    • Book Series
    • Coloring Books
    • Film Companions
    • Film Series
    • Hogwarts Library
    • Little Things
    • Music
    • Video Games
  • Fantastic Beasts
    • Book
    • Coloring Books
    • Film Companions
    • Fantastic Beasts Film Quotes
    • Film Series
    • Little Things
    • Music
    • Video Games
  • The Quibbler
    • Owl Post
    • Bathilda’s Notebook
    • The Department of MYTHteries
    • The Dirigible Plum
    • Into the Floo
    • Muggle Studies
    • The Pensieve Papers
    • The Three Broomsticks
    • April Fools’
    • The Quibbler Vault
  • The Daily Prophet
    • Book Trolley
    • Editorials
    • Event Reports
    • Exclusive Interviews
    • Features
    • Giveaways
    • Listicles
    • Merchandise Reviews
    • Movie Reviews
    • Television Reviews
    • Theater Reviews
    • Wizolympics
  • Muggle World
    • Charity
    • Exhibitions
    • J.K. Rowling
    • MinaLima
    • Quadball
    • Studio Tours
    • Theatrical Play
    • Theme Parks
    • Wizarding World Digital
  • Fans & Fun
    • Crazy Caption Contest
    • Fan Focus
    • Fandom
    • Fandom Sortings
    • Fandom Timeline
    • Fun Lists
    • Games and Trivia
    • GNOMEs
    • Potter DIY
    • Potter Weddings
    • #PotterItForward
    • Rosmerta’s Recipes
    • Song Parodies
    • Wizard Rock
    • Wizarding Wordle
  • Site
    • Contact Us & FAQ
    • History
    • Meet the Team
    • MuggleNet Live!
    • Press
    • Publications
    • Special Projects
    • Volunteer with Us!
    • Year in Review
  • Podcasts
    • Alohomora!
    • Full Circle
    • LITHAPPENS
    • Potterversity
    • Promptly Potter
    • SpeakBeasty
  • Harry Potter
    • Book Quotes
    • Book Series
    • Coloring Books
    • Film Companions
    • Film Series
    • Hogwarts Library
    • Little Things
    • Music
    • Video Games
  • Fantastic Beasts
    • Book
    • Coloring Books
    • Film Companions
    • Fantastic Beasts Film Quotes
    • Film Series
    • Little Things
    • Music
    • Video Games
  • The Quibbler
    • Owl Post
    • Bathilda’s Notebook
    • The Department of MYTHteries
    • The Dirigible Plum
    • Into the Floo
    • Muggle Studies
    • The Pensieve Papers
    • The Three Broomsticks
    • April Fools’
    • The Quibbler Vault
  • The Daily Prophet
    • Book Trolley
    • Editorials
    • Event Reports
    • Exclusive Interviews
    • Features
    • Giveaways
    • Listicles
    • Merchandise Reviews
    • Movie Reviews
    • Television Reviews
    • Theater Reviews
    • Wizolympics
  • Muggle World
    • Charity
    • Exhibitions
    • J.K. Rowling
    • MinaLima
    • Quadball
    • Studio Tours
    • Theatrical Play
    • Theme Parks
    • Wizarding World Digital
  • Fans & Fun
    • Crazy Caption Contest
    • Fan Focus
    • Fandom
    • Fandom Sortings
    • Fandom Timeline
    • Fun Lists
    • Games and Trivia
    • GNOMEs
    • Potter DIY
    • Potter Weddings
    • #PotterItForward
    • Rosmerta’s Recipes
    • Song Parodies
    • Wizard Rock
    • Wizarding Wordle
  • Features / The Daily Prophet

The Dumbledore Conundrum

by Lindsay Docken · October 29, 2018

When Rita Skeeter first announced the publication of The Life and Lies of Albus Dumbledore at the beginning of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, everyone – characters and readers alike – was in denial that the beloved Headmaster could ever do something scandalous enough to warrant such a salacious biography. This shock only grew throughout the novel as Harry Potter learns of Dumbledore’s troubled history with Grindelwald. By the time Dumbledore’s own brother, Aberforth, confirmed that Albus was a master of secrets and deceptions, we were all beginning to understand that there is so much more to the kindly old man than anyone thought. Then, when Harry allowed Dumbledore to explain himself in the ghost version of King’s Cross station, Dumbledore claimed that all of his mistakes stemmed from naivety and youthful love. In a nutshell, he claimed that the part of him that toyed with lies and duplicity was a mistake and not a character trait, but is this really the truth?

 

Dumbledore points to himself in the Mirror of Erised

 

I know it is hard to believe that the same man who consistently protected Harry and trolled the Dursleys with magical brandy in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince could also be a master manipulator. That, though, seems to be the best description of Albus Dumbledore. After watching the Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald trailer, it is readily apparent to me how much Dumbledore’s interactions with Newt Scamander mirror his interactions with Harry. For example, in the trailer, Dumbledore gives Newt a card and when asked about the address on it, Dumbledore responds that it is a nice place to go “for a cup of tea.” Sure, this is a witty one-liner on the surface, but underneath, this is only further proof exemplifying Dumbledore’s systemic avoidance of the full truth. On a broad scale, how is this any different from when Dumbledore told Harry he saw socks in the Mirror of Erised?

 

 

Dumbledore sends both Harry and Newt on dangerous, life-threatening tasks, in both cases claiming that he is unable to do them himself. Aside from the fact that Dumbledore could have 100% run his own errands, he gives both Newt and Harry very little information off of which to work. He waits 15 years before finally explaining to Harry why the Darkest wizard of his time is trying to kill him – not to mention that whole year Dumbledore flat-out avoided Harry! On top of that, once Dumbledore was forced to explain the prophecy, he did so in an ultimately vague way that left Harry relatively helpless on his journey for the Horcruxes. As far as I can tell, Dumbledore does the same thing to Newt in Crimes of Grindelwald. Dumbledore tells Newt that only he can work against Grindelwald, never explaining why and what kind of trouble Newt could be getting himself into. Don’t believe me? Well, going back to the card with the address on it, Dumbledore calls it a safehouse and Newt is confused about why he would need such a thing. If he really had been fully informed, Newt surely would understand the point of a Parisian safehouse – and it’s not for tea.

 

 

Dumbledore’s lack of candor is not only deceptive but also dangerous. He uses Harry like a pawn in his master chess game, and at this rate, he will do the same thing with Newt. Sure, you can argue that Dumbledore was doing everything to defeat Dark wizards and all that, but the real issue here is that he repeatedly twists people for his own plan, even for his own gain. He may be on the good side, but that doesn’t make him a morally good person. In fact, the most troubling aspect of Dumbledore’s manipulative nature is that he himself doesn’t see it. Each time, he blames his mistakes on age and emotion. With Harry, he claims he was an old man, blinded by his love for the young boy who had already been through so much. Similarly, Dumbledore claims that when he was with Newt, he was naïve and attempting to suppress his feelings for Grindelwald. These are certainly valid points and likely played a part in his actions, but you cannot deny that repetition of these follies suggests something more innate.

 

 

Ultimately, Dumbledore is a great a man, but he is not an infallible hero. What do you think? Do you think this is Dumbledore’s big character flaw, or was he just misguided? And don’t forget to go see young Dumbledore in Crimes of Grindelwald!

Social:

  • Next story Review & Giveaway: Magical Merchandise for “Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald”
  • Previous story UK and Ireland Get “Harry Potter” Cosmetics Range

MuggleNet Archive

Important Dates

July 2025

Tue, Jul 15

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - Part 2 movie
Recurs yearly

2011

Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince movie
Recurs yearly

2009

WWoHP at Universal Japan's anniversary
Recurs yearly

2014

Wed, Jul 16

Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince book
Recurs yearly

2005

Sun, Jul 20

Jeff Rawle's birthday
Recurs yearly

Amos Diggory

Stephenie McMillan's birthday (Set decorator - RIP)
Recurs yearly

Set decorator – RIP

Mon, Jul 21

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows book
Recurs yearly

2007

MuggleNet podcasts are sponsored in part by Secretlab.

Thanks to its research-backed ergonomic design, including a proprietary 4-way adaptive lumbar support system, the Secretlab TITAN Evo Harry Potter Edition will comfortably support you even when you’re up to no good.

Did You Know

If a wizard is buried with a wand made of yew, the wand sprouts into a tree that guards the dead owner’s grave.

Potter History

May 21-24, 2009 – The first LeakyCon is held in Boston, Massachusetts.

Potter Quote

“Well, that was a bit stupid of you, seeing as you don’t know anyone but me who’s been possessed by You-Know-Who, and I can tell you how it feels.”

MuggleNet is an unofficial Harry Potter fansite.
Please email us if you have any questions or concerns.
© 1999–2025 MuggleNet.com. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy | COPPA Policy | Terms of Use | Feedback


MuggleNet is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and Bookshop.org's affiliate program, affiliate advertising programs designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com and bookshop.org.